The TV series "Gazeta": review, criticism, cast, and plot of the spin-off of "The Office"

Contents:

• Events and plot lines of the series
• Responsibility for creating a spin-off: who is in charge?
• Achievements of the creators of "Gazeta"
• Failures of "Gazeta": what was left behind the scenes

On September 4, a series about the fate of a city newspaper editorial team in crisis debuted on the Peacock platform. The action takes place within the universe of the famous TV series "The Office," which aired from 2005 to 2013. Film critic Timur Aliyev observed the work of the Toledo Truth Teller editorial team and shares his impressions:

• The relationship between the "Newspaper" and the "Office" lies in their interaction and complementarity in the provision of information and services. The "Newspaper" serves as a source of news, current events, and analysis, while the "Office" is a space for work, collaboration, and management. These two elements can coexist, as the "Newspaper" informs the "Office" staff about external changes and innovations, while the "Office" provides the necessary conditions for processing and discussing this information. Thus, they form a unified whole, in which "The Newspaper" informs "The Office," and "The Office" provides a platform for applying the acquired knowledge.
• Domhnall Gleeson was chosen for the lead role for several reasons. Firstly, his acting talent and ability to deeply embody his characters attracted the attention of the directors. Gleeson has extensive experience working in various genres, allowing him to easily adapt to the demands of different roles.

  Furthermore, his charisma and expressiveness make him an ideal candidate for the central character. The directors working on the project noted that Gleeson's ability to convey complex emotions and create a compelling character is essential for a successful performance in a leading role.

  It's also worth considering that his previous work in film and theater has established him as a reliable and talented actor, which played a significant role in the casting decision.

• Gazeta examines modern journalism, focusing on the influence of algorithms, clicks, likes, and reposts. In an environment where information spreads instantly and audiences become increasingly demanding, media outlets face new challenges. The constant race for reader attention necessitates adapting content to meet users' current interests and preferences.

  Social media algorithms dictate which materials become popular, which, in turn, influences editorial decisions. Journalists are now forced to consider not only the quality of information but also how it will be received in the digital space. Likes and reposts are becoming indicators of success, which often leads to compromises in the depth of analysis and objectivity.

  As a result, modern journalism is undergoing a transformation, where the importance of sensational headlines and visuals often outweighs the content. This creates new challenges for professionals striving to maintain quality standards and ethical norms in an environment where audience attention is distracted and influenced by content trends.

• Humor is not always appropriate in this situation for several reasons. First, the perception of jokes can vary greatly depending on cultural and social contexts, which can lead to misunderstandings or even offense. Second, in serious or sensitive discussions, humor can be perceived as disrespectful to the topic or people involved. Finally, inappropriate jokes can distract from the main point of the discussion and reduce its seriousness, making it difficult to absorb important information.

Events and plot lines of the series

The Toledo Truth Teller, once a prominent publication with many journalists on staff, is now facing difficult times. The debt load is mounting, employees are leaving the company, and the number of readers of the print edition is rapidly declining. In a small corner of the office building, a tiny editorial office remains, which mainly publishes reprints of national news and sports results.

Enervate appoints Ned Sampson (Domhnall Gleeson) to the post TTT's new editor-in-chief. Sampson, who has a journalism degree, had previously worked only as a toilet paper salesman. From his very first days on the job, he declares his intention to do "real journalism." This displeases the managing editor, Esmeralda Grand (Sabrina Impacciatore), who advocates for adapting media to search engine and social media algorithms. As a result, Esmeralda begins to actively hinder all the changes that Ned seeks to introduce into the editorial activities.

Various employees work in the editorial office, including typesetter Meir (Chelsea Frye), advertising executive Dietrich (Melvin Gregg), and accountant and reporter Adelola (Gbemisola Ikumelo). Viewers will also be treated to a pleasant surprise: actor Oscar Nunez returns as the accountant from Dunder Mifflin. Familiar to fans of "The Office," Oscar Martinez has changed his career and is now responsible for the culture and entertainment section of the newspaper's editorial office.

Each of the ten episodes follows a similar structure. A specific event takes center stage—be it a high school football game, a minor squabble in the newspaper's editorial office, or a conflict at city hall. Members of the editorial team begin to exaggerate the scale of the incident, turning it into something resembling a federal scandal. Meanwhile, documentary cameras capture everything that happens, creating a series of scenes with emphasized pauses and flashes of enthusiasm.

Occasionally, the series' characters provide short interviews to the documentarians in a talking head format. Thus, Meir expresses dissatisfaction with the strict deadlines imposed by management. Dietrich laments the reduction in print advertising prices. Oscar, in turn, raises questions of professional ethics, occasionally recalling the intricacies of his interactions with Michael Scott.

The main narrative arc focuses on Sampson's efforts to prevent the closure of Toledo Truth Teller by changing his approaches to topics and formats. Some moments in the series seem to fail to advance the plot, but this can be seen as part of the creators' artistic intent. Awkward situations, mishaps, slips of the tongue and typos, high-profile failures and rare moments of character recovery—all of this makes up the everyday reality of the TTT editorial office.

Responsibility for the spin-off: who's running the process?

The showrunners of "The Newspaper" are Greg Daniels and Michael Koman. Daniels previously adapted the British version of "The Office" for American audiences. Koman, in turn, became known for the project "Nathan to the Rescue," which can be considered the basis for the series "The Rehearsal," starring Nathan Fielder.

The series "The Newspaper" appeared on viewers' screens quite quickly, which is a rarity these days. Typically, the process of creating foreign series takes from one and a half to two years. However, in this case, the team completed the task much faster: the first teaser was presented in January 2024, and filming began that summer. A few days before the release of the first episode, the project was renewed for a second season, which is unusual for new shows. The renewal decision was likely influenced by ideas Daniels already had for further story development, as well as NBCUniversal executives' confidence in the showrunner's abilities.

The creators of the project chose a style similar to that used in "The Office": "The Newspaper" is a classic mockumentary. The cameramen capture the characters' everyday lives, including elements of direct intervention, whether through interviews or hidden camera footage. Here, documentary verisimilitude is harmoniously intertwined with comedic elements. The lead role is played by Domhnall Gleeson, known for his roles in "About Time" and "Star Wars." This actor is primarily associated with dramatic roles, such as in "The Patient" and "Run." In "Gazeta," he fully demonstrates his comedic skills, as does Sabrina Impacciatore, who gained popularity thanks to her role in the drama "White Lotus," where she portrays Valentina, an attentive manager who easily copes with the whims of guests in the second season.

Read also:

Try this test, to find out which character from the series "The Office" is closest to your personality!

The Achievements of the Creators of "The Newspaper"

Every time the film industry attempts to revive classic works – be they old masterpieces or, as in the case of the series "The Office", more modern works (which ended in 2013) – it raises a certain concern. One of the most recent examples of this foreign craft is the reimagined version of "Ghostbusters", released in 2016, which was not warmly received by either critics or audiences.

The situation around "The Newspaper" is something similar, but with an emphasis on the creators. After all, the founders contributed to the creation of the spin-off, which gives the project additional legitimacy in the eyes of fans. The mockumentary format functions as gracefully here as in "The Office": the cameras working on the documentary don't follow the characters relentlessly 24 hours a day, but allow them to "step out of frame" from time to time.

The cameraman deserves special recognition for his skillful portrayal of the fading atmosphere of the provincial press. The abandoned corridors of the once glorious editorial office are now windy, and the outdated offices with shabby walls are cluttered with old issues of the newspaper.

At its most successful moments, "The Paper" captures those "hidden" seconds when the characters believe they are off-camera. These can be awkward pauses in response to questions, fleeting poses of contemplation while waiting for a cup of hot coffee, or a lingering glance at a colleague, full of admiration or irritation.

Domhnall Gleeson immediately captures the attention of viewers from the very first frames of the series. His character, Ned Sampson, is the central figure and soul of "The Paper." He himself claims that he "would rather remain Clark Kent than Superman, because it is much more noble." Don't expect the excessive comedy that was characteristic of Michael Scott in the early seasons of "The Office"; this editor-in-chief is an entirely different type. Ned is an idealist who fights for the values ​​of independent journalism. His arrival at the editorial office leads to the introduction of daily morning briefings, the creation of an "Investigative" section instead of simple reprints of national news, and a careful consideration of reader opinions. In the evening, discussions begin at TTT, where not only journalistic mistakes are analyzed but also ideas for new stories are generated.

Sabrina Impacciatore, who plays the cynical and at the same time highly emotional newsroom veteran, gives a truly impressive performance. The interaction between her character and Ned fills the season with many comic moments. The contradictions in their views open new horizons for understanding modern journalism methods.

In one of the central investigations of the season, Esmeralda obstructs the collection of witness statements. She submits false information about municipal contracts to the editorial office in order to obscure the newspaper's ties to city authorities. In response, Ned demands a thorough check of each document and meets with informants himself, insisting that Esmeralda act openly and adhere to journalistic standards.

In In 2025, when news reports often resemble the product of soulless algorithms, it's especially fascinating to follow how they are born "on the spot." Gazeta actively explores the intricacies of journalistic work, which in the age of social media, where anyone can become a reporter, has long lost its original essence. The mockumentary format lends this process a particularly natural feel: TTT's rookie reporters struggle, fumble over words, and drop their notebooks and pencils as they try to capture the speakers' words.

Read also:

From "The Office" to "The Split": we examine the disappearance of good sitcoms about working life.

The Failures of "Gazeta": What Remained Behind the Scenes

Although While the creators aimed to offer something unique, comparisons to "The Office" couldn't be avoided. Spin-offs are often viewed as secondary additions to an already established story. In this case, we're talking about a plot that many viewers adore and revisit at least every couple of years. Therefore, the appearance of Oscar Martinez's character is perceived as a provocation. If it were just a cameo, there would be no questions, but repeating in every episode that you're a direct continuation of "The Office"... In "The Paper," one can notice similarities in style, character roles, and the development of intercharacter relationships with the original show. However, one of the key aspects—the narrative pace—is significantly faster here. While in "The Office," the changes in character relationships occurred more naturally and leisurely (as, for example, in the romantic arc of Jim and Pam or the professional interactions of Dwight and Michael), in the spin-off, we see a rapid and sometimes artificial development of these relationships. The flirtation between Ned and Mair is reminiscent of Jim and Pam's dynamic, but it happens much faster.

As for the cast, the central pairing of Domhnall Gleeson and Sabrina Impacciatore is quite compelling for much of the series. However, the same can't be said for the rest of TTT's characters. It's difficult to convincingly claim that any of them displays depth or reveals their character traits: they mostly remain flat archetypes, fulfilling merely functional roles. Against the backdrop of the supporting cast of The Office, where each character had their own unique qualities, memorable lines, and distinctive characteristics, this becomes especially obvious.

Creating a comedy based on Criticism of the crisis in journalism faces certain difficulties. In "The Office," this concept was successful, as the atmosphere in a company selling paper and stationery was itself a model of absurdity. However, in this case, we are talking about independent journalism, which plays a key role in maintaining the democratic foundations of society.

The media crisis represents a significant social problem that requires support, not ridicule. It is especially sad to see Gazeta attempting to ridicule journalists from the provinces, who work under conditions significantly harsher than those faced by large federal media groups. This is not a reason to laugh at all - on the contrary, such a situation causes sorrow and implies the need to show sympathy, and not entertainment at the expense of other people's professional difficulties.

Read also:

Neighbors according to the script of "Friends": outstanding comedy series of the 21st century

In general, the show turned out to be high-quality, with a good dose of humor and, at times, even charming. However, it's impossible not to note the influence of "The Office," from which Greg Daniels and Michael Koman's new creation emerged. Viewers will certainly experience a sense of déjà vu—one of the main problems with sequels, prequels, and spin-offs.

If you ignore certain aspects, "The Newsroom" is a gripping narrative about people who maintain their professional dignity in difficult circumstances. This project is sure to attract the attention of fans of mockumentaries and fans of series that reveal the behind-the-scenes of the media, including those in the style of "The Newsroom." However, despite the famous name and talented creators, it is unlikely to become a significant cultural phenomenon.