Code

3 High-Profile Cases: Kaspersky Lab vs. Patent Trolls

3 High-Profile Cases: Kaspersky Lab vs. Patent Trolls

Cybersecurity Specialist: 5 Steps to a Successful Career

Find out more

Kaspersky Lab (KL) is not only one of the leading software developers, but also a significant defender of rights in the field of information technology. In our previously published articles, we examined how the company defended its interests in international courts, successfully refuting the actions of patent trolls. In this article, we continue our discussion of the important topic of intellectual property protection and the role of Kaspersky Lab in ensuring fairness in the industry.

The Conflict Between Wetro Lan and Kaspersky Lab

In 2016, Kaspersky Lab found itself at the center of a legal dispute with the American company Wetro Lan. Wetro Lan claimed that Kaspersky Lab infringed US Patent No. 6,795,918B1, registered in 2000. This patent describes technology related to "service-level computer security," which includes methods for filtering data packets. This case highlights the importance of patent enforcement in information security and may impact the development of technologies in this area.

Wetro Lan sought to adapt a firewall technology that had long been on the market. However, their version did not allow for manual configuration, which could lead to accidental user errors. This lack of flexibility and control makes the product less attractive to those who value customization and security.

Wetro Lan's owners are not the original developers of the patent. In 2015, they acquired the patent from the previous owner, who abandoned its support in 2012. As a result, the patent was not only inappropriate but also expired, calling into question the legality of its use.

Wetro Lan, despite its legal disadvantage, decided to exploit the shortcomings of the US patent system to its advantage. Specifically, under US law, companies can seek damages for patent infringement for up to six years prior to filing a lawsuit. This provides Wetro Lan with the opportunity to significantly increase its financial demands on competitors, which could have a significant impact on the market and the formation of patent strategies for other companies.

After acquiring the rights, Wetro Lan actively began filing lawsuits against various software developers in the Eastern District of Texas. The company's strategy was to, even with several victories, receive significant compensation for losses incurred in previous years. This line of business highlights the growing trend toward protecting intellectual property in the technology industry, where litigation is becoming an important tool for achieving financial goals.

Kaspersky Lab has significant experience in resolving such situations. As a result, Wetro Lan, lacking compelling grounds for its claims, gradually reduced the amount of its claim, starting with millions of dollars and ending up asking for only $10,000.

Kaspersky Lab made a counteroffer: Wetro Lan is willing to pay $10,000 and be released from further claims. This proposal looks attractive, especially considering that litigation could result in significant costs for both parties.

After brief negotiations, the parties agreed to pay Kaspersky Lab $5,000 and to waive any future lawsuits. This case demonstrates that patent trolls cannot operate with impunity, especially in the context of technologies that have been on the market for a long time. Kaspersky Lab confidently protects its interests and emphasizes the importance of respecting intellectual property in the technology sector.

A check from Wetro Lan for $5,000. Image: Eugene Kaspersky's blog
The decision in the Wetro Lan case. Image: Eugene Kaspersky's blog

Uniloc v. Kaspersky Lab

The lawsuit between the Australian-American company Uniloc and Kaspersky Lab is a significant event in the field of patent law. Since registering a patent for a software activation method in 1996 by the company's founder, Rick Richardson, Uniloc has been aggressively protecting its intellectual property rights. This patent provided protection for software from unauthorized use on various devices and became the basis for a number of legal disputes. This case highlights the importance of protecting intellectual property in the technology and software industries, and illustrates the complexity of litigation in this area.

In 2003, Uniloc significantly expanded its operations, creating a network of subsidiaries, including a branch in California. This strategic decision led to a series of lawsuits against large corporations such as Microsoft, Google, and Apple. In 2009, Uniloc achieved a significant victory in its lawsuit against Microsoft, opening new avenues for further lawsuits and making the company a notorious patent troll in the tech industry. This victory ushered in a new era of patent litigation, in which Uniloc became a key player, aggressively defending its intellectual property. By 2013, Uniloc had turned its attention to Kaspersky Lab. At this time, the defendant's position had significantly strengthened, and several leading IT companies joined forces to combat patent trolling. Damages from Uniloc's actions were estimated in the tens of millions of dollars, leading several companies to file a class action lawsuit with the US Patent and Trademark Office. This situation highlights the importance of protecting intellectual property in technology and the need for concerted action to combat unfair practices.

In 2012, Sega of America, Ubisoft, Cambium Learning Group, and several other prominent organizations sought to invalidate a software activation patent used by Uniloc in its lawsuits. After a three-year trial, the court invalidated the patent. The ruling came into force two years later, after numerous appeals, highlighting the importance of protecting intellectual property and its impact on the technology market.

Despite these setbacks, Uniloc continued its efforts. In 2016, it filed a new lawsuit against Kaspersky Lab, accusing it of infringing four patents related to license manager settings acquired from IBM. Uniloc had already filed similar lawsuits against companies such as Akamai, SAP, and Oracle. These actions highlight Uniloc's commitment to protecting its intellectual property rights and its commitment to protecting innovative technologies in the software licensing industry.

The trial concluded in 2020. Uniloc filed a lawsuit against Lab, seeking $90 million in compensation. However, experts estimated the actual amount of the potential payout at approximately $7 million. By the end of the trial, two of the patents were invalidated, and Uniloc decided to abandon further claims for the remaining patents.

Uniloc's Withdrawal of Claim. Image: Eugene Kaspersky's blog

It's unclear why Richardson changed his position. Perhaps he was persuaded by the mediation conducted by Kaspersky Lab, or by the company's reputation for decisiveness in litigation. It's also possible that he preferred to avoid repeating the negative experience of his colleagues at Wetro Lan and learned an important lesson about the need to consider one's options. This change in position may indicate his desire for a more balanced approach in difficult situations.

Statistics of Kaspersky cases in American courts. Image: Eugene Kaspersky's blog

Cybersoft IP, LLC v. Kaspersky Lab

One of the key patent law cases occurred in 2021 between Cybersoft IP and Kaspersky Lab. This trial became an important event in legal practice, highlighting the complexity and significance of patent disputes in the field of information technology and cybersecurity. This case attracted the attention of specialists and experts, as it concerned issues of intellectual property protection and the protection of innovative technologies. The resolution of this dispute could have a significant impact on the further development of patent law and practice in Russia and abroad.

In April 2021, Cybersoft IP filed a lawsuit in the US District Court of Massachusetts, alleging that Kaspersky Lab's Kaspersky Secure Mail Gateway solution infringes patent US6763467B1. This patent covers technologies and methods for intercepting network traffic, highlighting the importance of protecting intellectual property in the information technology sector. This case highlights the need to enforce patent rights and could impact the increasingly competitive cybersecurity market.

The disputed patent concerns data verification technology, including the analysis of emails and their attachments directly at the user device level. Experts estimate the potential damages for infringing this patent could reach approximately $500,000. This damage underscores the patent's significance in the context of intellectual property protection and the importance of enforcing rights to innovative data processing technologies.

Eugene Kaspersky, the company's founder, emphasized that this patent concerns technologies related to personal firewalls. These solutions have long been used in the industry to filter network traffic on user devices. Using personal firewalls effectively protects information and prevents unauthorized access to network resources, which is especially important in the face of growing cyber threats.

During the trial, Kaspersky Lab presented a number of compelling arguments that underscore its position. The company emphasized the importance of data protection and ensuring cybersecurity for users. Key arguments included evidence of the effectiveness of antivirus solutions, as well as statistics confirming the threat mitigation achieved through the use of their software. Kaspersky Lab also highlighted its achievements in developing secure technologies and its international recognition, confirming its status as a reliable player in the cybersecurity field.

  • The technology described in the patent was previously known (prior art).
  • The patent claims do not sufficiently disclose its capabilities.

The arguments presented during the trial created grounds for invalidating the patent. Kaspersky Lab's lawyers also successfully dismissed all indirect claims, focusing exclusively on those related to direct patent infringement. This decision may significantly impact future litigation and the protection of intellectual property in the field of cybersecurity.

As a result, the plaintiff, Cybersoft IP, agreed to an amicable resolution of the dispute at an early stage. Kaspersky Lab insisted on signing a covenant not to sue, which prohibits the parties from filing lawsuits against each other. This means that Cybersoft IP has lost the ability to bring claims not only against Kaspersky Lab, but also against all of its partners and customers. This agreement allows the parties to avoid further litigation and focus on more productive cooperation.

This case has become an important precedent in patent law, highlighting the importance of protecting intellectual property. It also illustrates the need for detailed verification of patents for their validity, which is key to ensuring fair competition and innovative development in various industries.

Effective Strategies Against Patent Trolls

Kaspersky Lab's experience shows that a proactive approach is the most effective strategy in countering patent trolls. Instead of passive defense, organizations should actively protect their interests and consider options for protecting themselves from the threats associated with patent disputes. Active measures, such as patenting innovations and monitoring violations, can significantly reduce risks and strengthen a company's position in the market.

If you are faced with obvious blackmailers whose demands have no legal basis, do not be afraid to use their methods against them. Using counterattacks can be more effective than standard defensive measures. It's important to remember that protecting your interests shouldn't violate the law. Be vigilant and act prudently to minimize risks and protect yourself from manipulation. Let your determination be your primary ally in this fight. It will help you overcome all obstacles and achieve your goals. Perseverance and self-confidence are key factors on the path to success. Use your determination as a powerful tool to achieve your desired outcome. Useful resources for in-depth study of this topic include a variety of online courses, webinars, articles, and specialized blogs. These sources will help you expand your knowledge and skills, as well as stay abreast of the latest trends and practices. It is recommended to pay attention to reputable platforms and experts in this field to receive relevant and high-quality information. Using these resources will allow you to effectively develop your competencies and achieve your goals.

  • Legal aspects of computer program protection
  • Test: determine where a real hacker attack took place
  • The Go language: its features and why it is worth learning as a second programming language

Cybersecurity: 5 Steps to a High-Demand Profession

Want to become a cybersecurity specialist? Find out how to master this profession from scratch!

Find out more