Code

Confidential Information and Trade Secrets: What a Programmer Needs to Know

Confidential Information and Trade Secrets: What a Programmer Needs to Know

Free Python Course ➞ Mini-course for beginners and experienced coders. 4 cool projects in the portfolio, live communication with the speaker. Click and find out what you can learn on the course.

Learn More

In this article, I discuss important aspects related to my professional work as a lawyer. I focus on confidentiality agreements, trade secrets, and trade secrets (know-how). I will share key points to consider before signing an employment contract and a non-disclosure agreement (NDA). A proper understanding of these documents will help protect your interests and avoid potential risks.

The article is based on three actual court cases, which will be explained from a legal perspective. To better understand the context, I will start with a brief legal primer.

You will receive information about:

  • what information is considered a trade secret and what is meant by it;
  • what is confidential information;
  • how confidential information differs from a trade secret;
  • how an employer can protect themselves and what an NDA is;
  • how a programmer can protect their interests.

What is a trade secret?

A trade secret is information that is valuable to a company and that contributes to its commercial gain. It is important to note that the definition of a trade secret is enshrined in law. According to the law, a trade secret includes information that is not publicly available and that an organization uses to achieve its business goals. Protecting such data is critical to maintaining a competitive advantage and ensuring the long-term stability of the company.

Of course, I am ready to help with editing the text. Please provide the text itself that you wish to change.

A trade secret is a confidentiality regime that protects certain information from disclosure. Owners of trade secrets can use them to increase revenue, minimize unnecessary expenses, and strengthen their position in the market for goods, works, and services. Protecting trade secrets also contributes to obtaining additional advantages and competitive advantages in business. Effective management of trade secrets is an important aspect for the sustainable development of a company and its successful functioning in a competitive environment.

A trade secret, or production secret, includes information of various categories - production, technical, economic, organizational, and other data. This also applies to the results of intellectual activity in the field of science and technology, as well as methods of conducting professional activities that have actual or potential commercial value. The commercial value of this information is due to its inaccessibility to third parties who do not have the legal right to receive such information. The owner of this information establishes a trade secret regime to protect its interests and prevent unauthorized use of the information.

Clause 1 and 2 of Article 34 of Federal Law No. 231-FZ of December 18, 2006 (as amended on December 30, 2015) regulate important aspects concerning the rights and obligations of parties in certain legal relationships. These clauses establish clear requirements and conditions that must be taken into account when carrying out activities related to this law. Proper understanding and application of these rules is key to ensuring compliance with the law and protecting the interests of all participants in the processes to which they relate. It is important to pay attention to the relevance of the amendments made to the law, as they may significantly affect the practical application of the rules and the procedure for interaction between the parties.

What is confidential information

Information is classified into four categories depending on the procedure for its provision or distribution.

  • freely distributed;
  • provided by agreement of persons involved in legal relations;
  • information that is subject to distribution in accordance with the law;
  • restricted access information.

The fourth category includes confidential information. This information requires special protection and handling, as it may contain data that, if disclosed, could cause harm to individuals or organizations. Confidential information may include personal data, financial information, trade secrets and other information that is not intended for public access. Proper management and protection of confidential information are key to ensuring security and trust in various fields of activity.

Information is classified by access categories. There is publicly available information, accessible to anyone, and information to which access is restricted by federal laws. The latter category is called restricted information.

Clause 2 of Article 5 of Federal Law No. 149-FZ of July 27, 2006, as amended on July 14, 2022, establishes key provisions regarding legal regulation in the field of information technology. This law regulates the use and dissemination of information on the Internet and ensures the protection of the rights of users and content creators. Importantly, the amendments made to the law in 2022 are aimed at improving working conditions in the digital space and increasing data security. Legislation in this area continues to evolve, highlighting the need to monitor current changes and adapt to new requirements.

The Difference Between Trade Secrets and Confidential Information

Confidential information is an important concept within the framework of trade secrets. According to legislation, in particular the Law "On Information...", confidentiality implies an obligation not to disclose information to third parties without the prior consent of its owner. Protecting confidential information is key to ensuring data security and maintaining a company's competitive advantage. Violation of these requirements can lead to legal consequences and loss of trust from customers and partners. Therefore, compliance with confidentiality rules is important for both organizations and individual entrepreneurs.

According to the Civil Code, if one party receives confidential information from the other party during contract negotiations, they are obligated to maintain confidentiality. This means that the information cannot be disclosed or used improperly for personal gain, regardless of whether a contract has been concluded. In the event of a breach of this obligation, the party that received the information is obligated to compensate the other party for any losses. Maintaining confidentiality in business relationships is an important aspect of protecting the interests of the parties and contributes to the development of trust.

Unlike confidential information, a trade secret is defined based on the conditions established by law. It is important to note that trade secrets may include information that has economic value and is not publicly available. The protection of such data is carried out in accordance with legal regulations, allowing companies to maintain a competitive advantage and ensure the security of their business processes. Disclosure of a trade secret can entail serious legal consequences and financial losses for an organization.

  • it has actual or potential commercial value due to being unknown to third parties;
  • access to it is limited on legal grounds;
  • the copyright holder introduces a special trade secret regime (we discussed it earlier).

The value of information constituting a trade secret directly depends on its secrecy. If the secret is disclosed, this value is lost. Unlike a trade secret, confidential information that is not related to it retains its value even if disclosed. However, the owner of such information may incur losses due to its disclosure. Therefore, the protection of trade secrets and confidential information is an important aspect of business, requiring a careful approach to minimize risks and losses.

In real practice, the concepts of "trade secret" and "confidential information" are often intertwined, which can negatively affect the information security of a company. Even when an employer enters into a confidentiality agreement with an employee, it is often executed incorrectly. This occurs due to a lack of clear legal guidance and insufficient legal literacy among those involved. A proper understanding and distinction between these concepts is critical for protecting corporate information and preventing leaks, making it essential to implement effective data security mechanisms within the company. Confidentiality agreements (NDAs) are an important information security tool and are used in various business sectors. They are concluded with employees, clients, and partners, ensuring the security of confidential data and intellectual property. Such agreements help prevent information leaks, which is especially important in a competitive environment. Properly executed NDAs promote the preservation of trade secrets and strengthen trust between the parties, which is the key to successful cooperation. Employers are advised to formalize a confidentiality agreement as a civil law contract, rather than as an appendix to an employment contract. This is because, in the event of a breach of employment contract terms, collecting a fine may be difficult, while direct actual damages can be recovered. It is important to note that this will require proof that the damage caused to the employer's property was caused by the employee's fault. This approach ensures more reliable protection of the employer's interests and facilitates more effective control over confidentiality. Confidentiality clauses are an important part of the employment contract and a separate non-disclosure agreement (NDA). These documents regulate the processing and protection of confidential information, ensuring the protection of both the employer and the employee. Including confidentiality clauses in the employment contract helps ensure that both parties understand their obligations regarding the confidentiality of corporate data and intellectual property. Thus, the presence of clearly defined confidentiality conditions contributes to a higher level of trust and security in the work process.

How a Kursk software engineer sued Rostelecom

In December 2011, the Kursk branch of Rostelecom fired a software engineer for disclosing trade secrets. In response to the dismissal, he filed a lawsuit in the district court, which was satisfied. This case highlights the importance of maintaining confidentiality in the field of information technology and protecting corporate information. Disclosure of trade secrets can lead to serious consequences for both employees and companies, which underscores the need for strict data security measures.

The regional court overturned this decision. According to the case materials, the software engineer had many years of experience at the company and was well versed in internal documents, including regulations regarding commercial secrets. Rostelecom presented the court with an employment contract and agreement signed by the plaintiff before starting work at the company. Despite the availability of these documents, the software engineer transferred the subscriber database on a flash drive to a sole proprietor who had previously worked with CenterTelecom. It is important to note that in 2011, CenterTelecom became part of Rostelecom, but the sole proprietor did not enter into a new agency agreement with Rostelecom. The court concluded that the plaintiff violated commercial secrets by transferring the database. This case highlights the importance of maintaining confidentiality and data protection in the telecommunications industry. According to the Labor Code, disclosure of legally protected secrets is a serious violation of employment obligations. This may result in the immediate dismissal of the employee, even if they have no previous disciplinary actions, warnings, or reprimands. Employers have the right to protect confidential information, and violating this protection can have serious consequences for labor relations.

According to Resolution No. 2 of the Plenum of the Supreme Court of the Russian Federation of March 17, 2004, the employer is responsible for providing evidence in certain situations. This includes the need to justify their actions and decisions regarding labor relations. The employer must confirm the legality of their demands and the justification for the measures taken, which plays an important role in resolving labor disputes. A key aspect is the employer's obligation to provide factual data and documents supporting their position. This principle promotes the protection of employees' rights and ensures fairness in labor relations.

  • the information disclosed by the employee is considered a trade secret in accordance with current legislation;
  • this information became known to the employee because he was performing his job duties;
  • he has undertaken not to disclose such information, that is, he was familiarized with the relevant job descriptions, regulations, and additional agreements by signature.

Dismissal of an employee for disclosure of a trade secret can be considered lawful only under certain conditions. To comply with the law, it is necessary to prove that the information is indeed confidential and its disclosure caused damage to the company. The employer must provide evidence that the employee was aware that the disclosed information was a trade secret and that he or she violated the relevant obligations. It is also important to consider that dismissal must comply with labor legislation, including compliance with procedural rules and regulations. Carefully documenting all stages of the process will help avoid potential legal consequences for the employer.

To fire an employee for disclosing trade secrets, the employer must provide evidence of their guilt. This is important, as the dismissal must be factual and comply with the law. The employer must gather all necessary documents and witnesses to justify their actions. A proper dismissal procedure will help avoid legal consequences and protect the company's interests.

How programmer K. won a lawsuit against Renaissance Insurance

Programmer K. began his career at Renaissance Insurance in 2006. He was familiar with the provisions on commercial secrets and signed a non-disclosure agreement. The employer has classified the following information as a trade secret:

  • the company's technological solutions;
  • software and hardware;
  • the content and logical architecture of databases and other information carriers;
  • know-how;
  • computer, telecommunications and other technologies.

In 2010, during an internal investigation, it was established that employees Z. and K. were developing an information system for competitors, using the know-how of Renaissance Insurance, namely the B2B system code. This discovery revealed serious violations of work ethics and jeopardized the company's competitiveness, since the use of internal information to create similar products by competitors can cause significant damage. It is important to consider that the protection of intellectual property and corporate secrets is a key aspect for the successful operation of any organization.

The B2B system is a web application designed to calculate the cost of products and generate accompanying documents. This system is actively used in online sales, ensuring efficiency and accuracy in the trading process. The program was developed by a team of specialists from Renaissance Insurance in 2007, confirming its reliability and experience in this field. The B2B system helps businesses optimize pricing processes and improve customer interactions, making it an indispensable tool in modern business.

Programmer K. was fired for disclosing trade secrets. He filed a lawsuit requesting that the dismissal wording be changed to "resignation at his own request" and demanded payment of wages for the period of forced absence, from the moment of dismissal until the court decision came into force.

The district court analyzed the case materials and concluded that the defendant failed to confirm the existence of a trade secret in the B2B system. Furthermore, the plaintiff was not accused of disclosing confidential information to third parties. Thus, the court's decision is based on the defendant's insufficient evidence.

The defendant did not indicate the grounds for K.'s dismissal in the order and did not provide evidence of measures taken to protect confidential information in accordance with the Law on Commercial Secrets. As a result, the court ruled in favor of K.

Renaissance Insurance filed an appeal against the court decision, but it did not produce the expected results. Higher courts noted that there was no evidence of K. transferring information related to a commercial secret to competitors.

To introduce a commercial secret regime with respect to certain information and establish employee liability, a number of requirements must be met. First of all, the organization must determine what information is subject to protection. This may include technologies, production processes, a customer base, or financial data. Next, it is necessary to develop internal documents regulating the procedure for handling confidential information. Including commercial secret provisions in employees' employment contracts is also an important step. Employees must be familiar with the rules and consequences of violating the commercial secret regime. Regularly training and informing employees about the significance and consequences of a data breach will help mitigate risks. It's also important to implement technical security measures, such as restricting access to sensitive data and using encryption. Compliance with these requirements will help effectively protect trade secrets and reduce the likelihood of information leaks.

  • define the list of such information;
  • restrict access to it - usually a local regulatory act is adopted, which determines the procedure for handling and control over information;
  • keep track of employees who have access to information - for example, keep a log;
  • regulate relations with these employees on the basis of employment contracts, and with counterparties - on the basis of civil law contracts;
  • apply the "trade secret" stamp and data on the copyright holder to tangible information carriers.

If an employee's job responsibilities involve access to a trade secret, the employer is obliged to: ensure confidentiality of the information, conduct training on the protection of trade secrets, conclude a non-disclosure agreement with the employee, and organize training on working with confidential data. These measures will help protect the company's interests and prevent the leakage of important information.

  • familiarize the employee with the list of such information, the established trade secret regime, and the penalties for violating it, against signature;
  • create conditions for compliance with this regime, that is, protect access to information related to a trade secret within the company.

If the employer does not comply with the established requirements, the employee's dismissal may be considered illegal. It is important that all procedures related to dismissal comply with the law. Otherwise, the employee has the right to challenge the decision in court or the labor inspectorate. Proper compliance with all stages of dismissal will help avoid legal consequences and protect the interests of both the employer and the employee.

In order to hold the employee responsible for disclosing confidential information, the employer must establish a trade secret regime. This includes the development and implementation of internal regulations defining the procedure for handling classified information, as well as the need for employees to sign non-disclosure agreements. This approach protects the company's interests and minimizes the risk of important information leaks.

How Performance Expert Accused a Team Lead of Deleting Distributions

Performance Expert filed a lawsuit against Sh. for violating confidentiality terms and demanding compensation. Sh. had held the position of team lead since February 2017 and had access to the company's trade secrets, and also signed a non-disclosure agreement (NDA). Violating the terms of this agreement can entail serious consequences both for Sh. and for the company, which seeks to protect its interests and maintain competitiveness in the market.

In February 2018, Sh. decided to resign of his own free will. A month after his dismissal, during the reinstallation of the software stand, the employer noticed that the previous stand had been removed and the necessary software distributions were missing. This situation raises questions about data storage and transfer procedures, as well as the importance of documenting company processes.

During the investigation, it was discovered that the defendant had access to Yandex.Disk, where the necessary distributions were stored. On February 25, 2018, an unknown individual logged into his account and deleted files from both the disk and the Recycle Bin. The distribution packages could not be restored, resulting in losses for the company in the amount of 2,287,773.76 rubles.

Performance Expert filed a lawsuit against the defendant demanding 500,000 rubles for violating the terms of the confidentiality agreement (NDA) and 583,099.91 rubles for material damages.

The plaintiff provided the court with a copy of the expert's report and the inspection report, which confirm that unauthorized software removal was performed from the defendant's email.

The employment contract provides for a fine of 500,000 rubles, which is applied as a sanction for disclosure of confidential information. This amount, in addition to compensation for damages arising from the breach of the contract, emphasizes the importance of maintaining the confidentiality of information.

The defendant dismissed Performance Expert's claims, declaring that he had not committed the actions he was accused of. He noted that the employer had made no claims upon dismissal and that there was no evidence of actual damages. Furthermore, the employer had failed to ensure the protection of confidential information in accordance with legal requirements.

Mail.ru responded to the court's request, stating that, according to the terms of the user agreement, only individuals can own mailboxes. However, the company could not confirm the ownership of a specific mailbox by a specific person. This verification limitation creates difficulties in identifying users and protecting their rights.

The court took into account the following factors:

  • after the defendant's dismissal, the employer failed to take the necessary measures to secure the software;
  • the registration of a postal address in the name of Sh. is not proof that the illegal actions were committed by the defendant;
  • at the time of the trial, the software had been restored and the plaintiff's obligations to the counterparties had been fulfilled, meaning there was no evidence that Sh. had caused actual damage to the company.

The court noted that the fine of 500,000 rubles was imposed in accordance with current legislation. This fine is a measure of liability for the violation, which underscores the seriousness of the situation. It is important to consider that such financial sanctions can significantly impact the violator's activities and serve as a warning to other participants. In such cases, the court takes into account all the circumstances of the case, which helps ensure fairness and legality in making decisions.

  • The plaintiff did not provide evidence that Sh. disclosed the company's confidential information to third parties;
  • The plaintiff did not confirm that Sh. caused damage to the company in the amount of a certain amount.

The Labor Code does not establish fines for disclosure of confidential information. This means that the condition of the employment contract signed by Sh. worsens his position compared to the current legislation. Therefore, this condition is contrary to the law and can be recognized as invalid.

The district court dismissed the claim of the Performance Expert company, and the appellate court upheld this decision, leaving it unchanged.

How an employer can protect himself

The confidentiality agreement should include an exact list of information related to confidential information. Typically, such a list is drawn up as an appendix to the NDA. In practice, companies also transfer confidential information through separate acceptance certificates, which helps reduce the risk of confidentiality being challenged in litigation. This ensures reliable protection of valuable business and intellectual property.

It is important to clearly distinguish between generally confidential information and trade secrets in the agreement, as the latter is subject to stricter legal requirements. The methods for protecting these two types of information also differ. Trade secrets must be given a special protection regime, regardless of whether they are included in a non-disclosure agreement (NDA). This will ensure adequate protection of your intellectual property and prevent potential information leaks.

When addressing the property liability provisions in a confidentiality agreement (NDA), it is important to consider important aspects. If the document includes an indemnification clause, it should be understood that the existence of these losses and their exact amount must be proven in court. The key is to establish a causal link between the disclosure of confidential information and the damages incurred. This allows you to protect your interests and ensure fair compensation for losses incurred.

If the penalties include fines, specific amounts should be specified for different types of confidentiality violations. This will provide the courts with grounds to satisfy the information owner's claims, without the owner being obliged to prove the amount of damages incurred. Clarifying fines for violations helps create a more transparent legal environment and promotes compliance with confidentiality standards.

How an employee can protect their interests

Remember the key provisions of the law discussed in this article. These aspects are important for understanding the legal rules and regulations that may affect your activities. Pay attention to the main principles and provisions, as they will help you better navigate the legal environment.

When signing an employment contract and confidentiality agreements, it is extremely important to carefully read their terms. This will help avoid future misunderstandings and protect your rights. Make sure you understand all the terms of the document before signing. Don't neglect this recommendation, as it can significantly impact your career and the protection of your personal information.

Before signing the line "I have read the employer's internal regulations regarding commercial secrets," be sure to carefully review these documents. This will help you avoid misunderstandings and protect your rights. By signing such documents, you confirm that you are aware of the rules and conditions regarding the company's confidential information. Therefore, take the necessary time to familiarize yourself with the content and specifics of the employer's internal regulations.

It is recommended that you contact specialists, such as lawyers and information security personnel, to clarify any points in the employment contract, non-disclosure agreement (NDA), or internal documents that raise questions. This will help ensure proper understanding of all terms and prevent potential legal issues in the future.

According to the law, there is a specific list of information that cannot be considered a trade secret within a company. If an employer includes any of this information on this list, the corresponding clause of the contract or internal regulation will be deemed invalid. This rule also applies in cases where there are contradictions between the employer's internal regulations, such as an employment contract or non-disclosure agreement, and current legislation. It is important to consider these aspects to ensure the legality of working conditions and the protection of employees' rights.

If you have any doubts about confidential information, be sure to clarify the situation by asking your manager, a representative of the legal department, or an information security officer. As a lawyer, I strongly recommend formulating requests in writing to create a paper trail and increase the transparency of communication. This will help avoid misunderstandings and ensure the protection of your interests and the interests of the company.

Read also:

  • Guide to proprietary licenses and software protection: types, characteristics, examples
  • How to get into a Big Four company at 22: the story of data scientist Artem
  • Guide to free licenses from GNU: what they are and what types there are