Contents:

Dreaming of remote work? ➞ Study IT, design, or marketing. Take 5 online courses to launch a career in in-demand digital professions.
Learn moreIn this material, you will learn about the following aspects:
- Who is the author of the famous quote and what meaning did the creator put into it?
- The question of the applicability of the rule "what doesn't kill you, makes you stronger" in the field of psychology is of interest. This phrase suggests that the difficulties and experiences a person faces can lead to their inner strengthening and development. However, it is worth noting that not all situations operate according to this principle.
Psychologists argue that stressful events can both strengthen the personality and have a negative impact on mental health. For example, overcoming serious challenges can contribute to the development of resilience and increased self-confidence. In this case, the experience proves beneficial and promotes growth.
On the other hand, not all experiences lead to positive changes. Traumatic events can leave deep psychological scars, contributing to the development of various disorders, such as depression or post-traumatic stress disorder. The level of support from others and personal resources also play a significant role in how a person copes with difficulties.
Thus, the rule "what doesn't kill you, makes you stronger" is not universal. Individual characteristics, context, and circumstances determine whether a challenge will lead to growth or, conversely, to a decrease in psychological well-being.
- Living by such a motto can be risky for several reasons. First of all, such an attitude can lead to ignoring reality and neglecting important aspects of life. This can cause serious problems in interpersonal relationships, as a person adhering to this principle may not take into account the feelings and needs of others.
Furthermore, such an approach can contribute to the development of irresponsibility. If you ignore the consequences of your actions, you can find yourself in difficult situations that will make your life more difficult. Finally, this can negatively impact your mental health, as the constant tendency to ignore difficulties and problems prevents you from finding solutions and overcoming them.
Thus, living by such a motto can lead to many negative consequences that affect both personal and social aspects of life.
- What really gives us strength in difficult times?
We have created a Telegram channel called "How are you?" In this convenient format, we will share information about self-development, psychology, as well as how to successfully study and develop a career at any age. Join us!
The author of the famous phrase "What does not kill you makes you stronger"
This statement belongs to Friedrich Nietzsche, a German philosopher who lived in the 19th century. However, the true meaning that this outstanding thinker and man passionate about aphorisms put into his words remains a mystery.
There is an opinion that Nietzsche, in his reflections on the transformation of man into a "superman," means an individual who has rejected moral norms and social rules, overcome the desire for comfort and recognition, and also formed his own values. Such a superman, according to Nietzsche, destroys the usual boundaries and ceases to exist within the binary division into "good" and "bad." For him, the concepts of good and evil have no meaning.
According to Nietzsche, absolute freedom of the individual and objective truth without value judgments represent the highest stage of human evolution. The philosopher was likely pointing to the process by which a person moves toward this metamorphosis, emphasizing that we become stronger by overcoming painful experiences and difficult life circumstances.

However, it is unlikely that people today, when turning to this quote, reflect on the development of our fussy bipedal species. More often than not, we resort to Nietzsche's words to console ourselves or others when faced with financial difficulties, stress, illness, or psychological trauma. However, this interpretation of his thoughts can be questioned.
The Problems with the Saying "What Doesn't Kill You Makes You Stronger"
From a psychological perspective, this statement flies in the face of objective facts. Numerous studies show that many individuals who survive natural disasters and natural calamities suffer from the consequences of their experiences for many years. In terms related to Nietzsche's philosophy, the idea that "it makes us stronger" looks like this:
- According to research, 24% of people who are victims of natural disasters are at risk of developing post-traumatic stress disorder (PTSD) within six months of the disaster.
- 28% of those who survive it will experience various manifestations of depression.
- 23% of people may develop severe anxiety.
While PTSD usually gradually weakens, manifestations of depression and anxiety can persist for months and even years, debilitating those who experience them.
The prognosis for women who have experienced domestic violence is not optimistic. Even those who manage to muster up the courage to leave a toxic relationship often continue to experience deep depression for several months after the breakup. Additionally, living with a violent and aggressive partner can have serious consequences:
- the development of long-term pain;
- the development of arterial hypertension and migraine headaches;
- hearing or vision loss;
- sleep problems and digestive disorders, which can lead to eating disorders;
- the progression of coronary heart disease;
- the development of alcohol or drug addiction.
Constantly experiencing stress at work, at home, or in personal relationships leads to burnout. By ignoring the need for self-help or seeking support from specialists, a person not only does not progress, but also gradually harms their emotional state.
Ultimately, difficult experiences are unlikely to strengthen us. They are often debilitating, require significant time to recover from both mental and physical trauma, contribute to fears, and hinder our further development. People who have experienced domestic violence often fear new relationships or, conversely, unconsciously gravitate toward similar experiences with a new aggressor. Those who have experienced the loss of a home or family as a result of tragedy may find it difficult to cope with the weight of loss, and they may retreat into the shadows for extended periods, turning to alcohol, gambling, risky sexual behavior, and other addictions. What doesn't kill you often leads to long-term psychological imbalance and poisons your life.

Read also:
Post-traumatic stress disorder (PTSD) is a serious mental illness that occurs as a result of experiencing traumatic events. It can present with a variety of symptoms, including intense flashbacks of the event, avoidance of situations reminiscent of the trauma, and increased vigilance and emotional instability.
The causes of PTSD can vary, but it is most often associated with extreme experiences such as war, natural disasters, violence, or serious accidents. Individual factors, including previous trauma, level of support from loved ones, and personality traits, can also play a significant role in the development of the disorder.
Treatment for PTSD can include both psychotherapy and medication. Psychological treatment can focus on processing the traumatic experience and learning coping techniques. It's important to remember that support from family and friends can make the recovery process much easier.
It's likely we'll be able to prevent many tragic outcomes if we abandon the heroic stoicism proposed by Nietzsche and recognize in time that situations that don't lead to immediate death, but bring us closer to a dangerous line, require attention, care, and support.
Reasons to doubt this phrase in everyday life
Ultimately, it all comes down to another quote: "What kills us makes us dead." Thus, writer Terry Pratchett interpreted Nietzsche's famous thought.
The crux of the problem is that Nietzschean philosophy, when applied to everyday life, can foster a desire for endless goal-achievement and overcoming difficulties, giving rise to the belief that experiencing difficulties is a sign of weakness, and that expressing one's feelings or asking for help is unacceptable. Moreover, it can promote the idea that one should endure and expect to be "enriched" through suffering and trials.
Children raised in conditions of obvious cruelty at the hands of their parents sometimes claim, "So what, they beat me, and I still turned out okay. That means it was right; I learned something." Their opinion is that they weren't beaten to death, but merely hardened, made more resilient. Therefore, can we assume that it is acceptable to hit one's own child in certain situations? Increased violence and suffering can be another potential "gift" of a misunderstanding of Nietzsche's philosophy in real life.
In such situations, it should be taken into account that much more often people overcome difficulties and face cruelty from others not by hardening themselves in it, but by finding the strength to survive.
A man who was disciplined with a belt as a child does not resort to violence as an adult, not because he has become psychologically resilient from these traumatic experiences, but because he has found the strength to resist the negative consequences. Yes, he didn't break down and, fortunately, avoided developing a complex associated with depression, anxiety and low self-esteem. However, he likely expended significant psychological resources on overcoming these difficulties, which, in a more supportive and respectful environment, could have been directed toward developing creativity, studying, and building healthy relationships with others.
A person is not made of metal: under stress and trials, we do not become stronger, but rather expend our internal resources.

In life, there are also cases of interactions with aggressive and narcissistic partners. Their cruelty and emotional manipulation do not contribute to strengthening relationships. On the contrary, they undermine trust in the world around us and other people, causing passive aggression and internal doubts - this leads to a destructive effect on the psyche.
Although at first glance it may seem that a person who has experienced real trials appears indifferent and unwavering, successful and firm in their decisions, this does not mean that they have become stronger.
They most likely withdrew, straining all their internal supports as much as possible and hiding their true self behind a strong emotional shell. This protection, like thorns, can inflict harm on both the individual and those who dare approach.
Certainly, there are unique cases where people who have lost limbs or overcome serious illnesses and tragedies actually acquire a certain "immunity" to life's difficulties. However, this does not mean that wisdom, happiness, and kindness are available only to those who have faced difficult trials. Harmony with oneself and the world around us is achieved through awareness and reflection, through the desire to find meaning in life and a strong connection with personal values.
Don't thank difficult times. However, you yourself deserve recognition. You overcame difficulties because you initially possessed inner strength. You coped and survived a difficult period.
