Contents:

Course with employment: "The profession of a Methodologist from scratch to PRO"
Find out moreIn the United States, there are many colleges and universities offering fully online education, allowing students to study at their own pace. These educational institutions can be both private and public. Interest in online education is growing every year. According to the Best Colleges platform, in 2020, there were 422 online colleges in the United States, with over two million students enrolled, representing 15% of the country's total student population. Let's take a closer look at how online learning is organized and what criticisms have been leveled at it. Let's examine the differences between colleges and universities in the United States. Colleges are generally smaller than universities in terms of the number of educational programs and students. However, they can also be considered higher education institutions and offer undergraduate programs. Master's programs are extremely rare at colleges, as this level of education is usually offered only at universities. It's important to note that colleges can be part of universities, similar to how large universities in Russia can include several institutions.
Most often, colleges in the United States offer programs similar to our secondary vocational education or continuing professional education courses. Upon completion of these programs, students receive professional certificates. These certificates are official documents confirming that their holder has the necessary knowledge and skills to successfully work in a particular profession. Obtaining a professional certificate opens new employment opportunities and promotes career advancement.
Online colleges and online universities offer both undergraduate and short-term certificate programs. These institutions attract working adults who seek to improve their skills and enhance their qualifications without having to attend a traditional educational institution. Online education provides flexibility, allowing you to balance your studies with work and personal commitments.
How Large Online Colleges and Online Universities Work
These new types of educational institutions are organized around online platforms with asynchronous courses. There are no semesters, allowing students to study at their own pace. The duration of training can vary depending on the individual approach. Students can view classes at any time, participate in webinars, and submit assignments online. Upon completion of the course, they receive a certificate or diploma confirming their achievements. These educational formats are becoming increasingly popular due to their flexibility and accessibility, making learning more effective and adapted to modern requirements.
Western Governors University, located in Utah, is the oldest and largest private university in the United States. Each year, approximately 150,000 students enroll exclusively online. Western Governors offers full-degree programs, not just certificates of completion. Students can choose from a variety of programs, including IT, marketing, finance, management, and accounting. This university offers flexible learning opportunities, making it attractive to students seeking to balance their studies with work or other commitments.
Competency-based education allows students to learn at their own pace. However, to earn credit or a degree, students must demonstrate their knowledge and skills. All interactions with university representatives take place online. Unlike traditional colleges, there can be one faculty member per 230 students. Students can seek support from mentors who can help them resolve issues and develop their curriculum. Approximately 700 raters, who are not familiar with the students, evaluate completed assignments. This ensures objectivity and independence in the grading process. Southern New Hampshire University is the second-largest university in the world, with an enrollment of 145,000 students. Of this number, only 6,000 are enrolled in full-time classes, representing less than 10% of the total. The university's learning format differs from the traditional "free schedule": students receive access to course materials, assignments, and course descriptions one week before classes begin. After consulting with a professor or advisor, students can study at their own pace while adhering to set deadlines. Undergraduate courses last eight weeks, and advanced courses last ten weeks. There are more than eight thousand contract teachers, and their income per semester does not exceed two and a half thousand dollars, which is significantly below the cost of living in the country.

Student performance is assessed based on the assignments they submit. At Western Governors University, students must submit essays, videos, or presentations, which instructors use to evaluate their understanding of the material. At Southern New Hampshire University, assessments are submitted weekly, without traditional class periods. Instructors analyze performance, including compliance with test deadlines and other assignments, to determine how well students have mastered the course material. This approach allows for more flexible and objective assessment of student knowledge, which contributes to the improvement of the educational process.
This approach has drawn justified criticism in academic circles. Colleges' complete reliance on Uber-style instructors may seem financially expedient, but from an academic perspective, it creates significant risks. The lack of continuity and permanent faculty negatively impacts the quality of education. Moreover, working under precarious conditions, without a living wage or social security, is viewed as exploitative. Robert Ubell, dean of the Polytechnic Institute of New York University, highlights this in his column on online colleges. These issues highlight the need to rethink approaches to organizing the educational process in the context of digitalization of education.
The popularity of online colleges and universities is driven by the ease of completion and lower tuition compared to traditional institutions. According to HolonIQ experts, by 2030, the share of online programs in US higher education will reach almost one-third, but hybrid learning formats will remain the most common.
Research shows that the situation with online learning is not so straightforward. First, many students frequently drop out, making it significantly longer to earn a degree or certificate compared to traditional colleges. Second, repaying student loans is more difficult. While this problem is not as pressing for the Russian market, for Americans, student debt is becoming a serious financial burden.
Why this online model is criticized
Colbright College, California, founded in 2018, has become a shining example of accessible online education. It offers state residents the opportunity to receive a free education in a convenient format. Funding for the college comes from the state budget, making education accessible to everyone. Colbright's primary audience is not only high school graduates but also adults who seek to quickly acquire new knowledge for retraining or complete their general education. Colbright provides unique opportunities for those seeking high-quality and affordable education in the modern world.
The college offers a variety of educational programs that allow graduates to work from both home and in the office. While the number of specializations is limited, Colbright offers programs in technical support, information security (IT experience required), CRM platform administrator, and medical programmer. These programs are tailored to meet the needs of the modern labor market and ensure a high demand for specialists in various fields.
The curriculum is based on a competency-based approach. Students can begin their studies at any time, as the college does not have mandatory lectures or seminars. Instead, they receive support from online instructors and tutors, as well as access to free e-textbooks. Students can rent tablets and modems, which is especially important for those who do not have their own equipment.
The college states that with classes ranging from 6 to 12 hours per week, most programs can be completed in six months. However, graduates receive a certificate, not a diploma, confirming successful completion of the program and passing the required tests.
The college has experienced significant problems with its graduates: by 2021, its number had dropped to only 70. Furthermore, of the 518 students enrolled at the college this year, only 129 were actively enrolled. This highlights a common problem for EdTech platforms: low student completion rates. Effective solutions for increasing student engagement and retention are becoming critical to the successful functioning of educational institutions.
State officials have expressed dissatisfaction with Colbright's activities. Despite the university's improved performance, its closure has become a topic of discussion for the third time. Politicians argue that the millions of dollars allocated to support the online university could be used to fund traditional colleges, where graduation rates significantly exceed Colbright's.
The institution faced a number of serious problems. One of the key challenges was the unreasonably high salaries of administrative representatives. This caused discontent among employees, who doubted the veracity of data on supposedly active students. There were also concerns about possible deception on the part of state authorities, which exacerbated the situation within the institution. Financial and management problems negatively impacted the institution's reputation and its interactions with government agencies.

Despite the existing problems, the popularity of Colbright College continues to grow. According to CalMatters, the school enrolled 2,300 students from California in 2022, with enrollment growing by 8% monthly. The total enrollment is expected to reach approximately 3,000 by summer. Meanwhile, in the second quarter of 2022, 70% of students were active, indicating they successfully completed courses and homework. However, despite the high level of engagement, graduation rates remain low: as of 2023, less than 10% of students were able to earn their certificates within a year. This aspect requires additional attention and improvement at the educational level.
At Southern New Hampshire University, according to Robert Ubell, the student retention rate in courses reaches 90%. This is a figure that is the envy of many EdTech platforms. High success rates attest to the quality of the educational programs and effective teaching methods used at the university.
Is there similar experience in Russia?
Is there similar experience in Russia?
Currently, there are no universities in Russia that offer fully online education. However, public and private universities offer higher education programs online. Most often, such programs are organized in collaboration with EdTech platforms. For example, RANEPA, St. Petersburg Polytechnic University, Moscow State Pedagogical University, Ural Federal University, and Moscow Institute of Physics and Technology implement online programs in partnership with platforms such as Skillbox and Skillfactory. In May 2023, HSE University launched its online campus, "HSE Online," which includes three undergraduate and 16 master's programs available online, as well as short courses. Some private colleges also offer fully online departments. Thus, online education in Russia is rapidly developing, offering students a wide range of educational programs.
Explore additional resources:
- Main areas of collaboration between universities and EdTech: a British perspective on prospects
- What is self-regulated learning and why is it important for both EdTech and universities?
- Is EdTech development a threat to universities? What do the experts think? target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer">Learn more

