Education

CRAFT/ED: What is this tool for educational designers?

CRAFT/ED: What is this tool for educational designers?

Course with employment: "The profession of a Methodologist from scratch to PRO"

Find out more

To improve the effectiveness of training, it may be necessary to change the educational methodology or environment. In particular, it is important to reconsider the interactions between participants in the educational process, whether they are teachers and students or interactions between students themselves. Changing these aspects can significantly improve students' attitudes towards the course. Such changes can:

— Increase student motivation, which promotes deeper learning.
— Promote student active participation in the learning process, which improves their collaboration and communication skills.
— Increase the level of engagement, allowing students to feel their importance in the learning process.
— Help tailor teaching approaches to individual student needs, which makes classes more personalized and effective.
— Create a more positive classroom atmosphere that promotes the exchange of ideas and the development of critical thinking. Thus, changing the interactions and attitudes of participants in the educational process can significantly improve the quality of learning and student satisfaction. Motivate students; Overcome internal barriers; Develop a specific skill; Convey values. Creating a lesson scenario or program with new relationships, non-standard participant roles, and diverse forms of interaction is a task that requires a creative approach. The CRAFT methodology, developed by the authors with an emphasis on creativity and innovation, is ideally suited to achieving these goals. We examined how exactly it functions and what advantages it can offer in the process of developing unique educational programs. Using CRAFT not only allows for a diversification of approaches to interaction but also a deeper understanding of the roles of participants, which contributes to more effective learning and development.

What is the CRAFT methodology?

The development of creative ideas is carried out through the formation of new relationships, roles, and contexts in various fields, such as IT, marketing, sales, the gaming industry, and the entertainment industry. This process allows for the discovery of unique solutions and approaches that promote innovation and effective development in each of these areas. The use of creative methods in these areas not only improves the quality of products and services but also increases the competitiveness of companies in the market.

The creators of the CRAFT methodology claim that it significantly optimizes project processes through the introduction of role models. The author of the methodology is Vasily Lebedev, head of the IKRA School of Innovation. He emphasizes that the foundation of this methodology is the work of the French sociologist Bruno Latour, as well as the ideas of Georgy Shchedrovitsky's system-activity methodology and the American sociologists George Mead and Erving Goffman. The authors' official website offers a limited description of the CRAFT methodology, but a more detailed explanation can be found in the book "CRAFT: How to Create Big Ideas." The release of a new book dedicated to the application of the CRAFT methodology in educational institutions has also been announced. The CRAFT methodology offers an innovative approach to organizing teamwork and can become a key tool for improving efficiency in various fields. Daria Savelyeva, educational program designer and curator of the IKRA School of Innovation, collaborated with Artemy Lebedev to adapt the CRAFT methodology for the creation of educational products. This approach is called CRAFT/ED. In an interview with Skillbox Media, she shared details about this methodology and its application in education. CRAFT/ED is aimed at improving the quality of educational programs and developing innovative approaches to teaching.

What is CRAFT/ED? ...Daria claims that the CRAFT/ED methodology was developed to quickly find effective ideas aimed at solving problems or objectives of the curriculum. This approach is especially useful in conditions of time constraints, when it is necessary to quickly find inspiration. The CRAFT/ED methodology is suitable both for creating individual learning activities and for developing and improving entire educational courses.

The methodology consists of four steps that may seem fairy-tale, but in practice they are quite realistic. The first step is to define the problem that needs to be solved. Then comes the generation of ideas for solving this problem. After that, the ideas are transformed into specific implementation mechanisms. The final stage is a thorough testing of the interaction of these mechanisms with each other and with the existing curriculum, if any. If inconsistencies are identified, it is necessary to consider ways to resolve them in accordance with didactic principles and rules. This methodology allows for the effective improvement of educational programs and their adaptation to the needs of students.

Here are the four main steps of the CRAFT/ED method.

The first step is to clearly define the problems and tasks that require solutions. The wording should be clear and specific. For example, the phrase "the student does not want to study" is abstract and does not provide an understanding of the essence of the problem. Before developing a solution, it is important to understand why the student is not interested in learning. A thorough analysis of the reasons will allow you to develop effective strategies for increasing motivation and engagement in the educational process.

There are five effective methods for diagnosing the problem. You can apply all of them or choose only those that best suit your situation.

  • Role model analysis (helps to analyze the current role model of relationships and identify problems in it);
  • Barrier analysis (we discover what hinders learning);
  • Motive analysis (what do students want?);
  • Values ​​analysis (if we want to include a value in the program that will help graduates apply the acquired skills and knowledge more effectively);
  • Skills analysis (we clarify the skills that we want to emphasize in the program).

Thus, we move on to formulating a specific problem in the format of "how to achieve ..." and realize what aspects should be taken into account when developing a course. This may include barriers, motivation, values, or other key factors. A proper understanding of these elements will help you create a course that will be effective and in demand, meeting the needs of the target audience and contributing to the achievement of the set goals.

Once you have defined your problem, it is worth looking for situations unrelated to learning where you can find a suitable solution. It's important to step away from familiar reality and explore other contexts, allowing your imagination to develop freely. This will help open up new perspectives and ideas that may be applicable to your situation. By exploring different "frames," you may find innovative approaches you haven't previously considered.

Daria recommends searching for ideas in key categories of situational analysis. Consider social, natural, ritual, historical, professional, and artistic aspects. These areas can inspire new ideas and aid in the creative process.

To unite and motivate a team, it's important to ask yourself: in what context do people feel part of a unified whole? One option is to use scenarios related to surviving a zombie apocalypse, which falls under the artistic situational category, or bomb defusing, which falls under the professional situational category. If your goal is to develop a specific skill, such as the ability to find solutions under conditions of limited resources and high uncertainty, consider suitable scenarios. For example, a scenario involving a trip to Mars perfectly illustrates this ability. In such a setting, the team would need to improvise and adapt, solving problems such as repairing a rover using available materials. These situations foster creativity and teamwork, which in turn strengthens team cohesion.

Explore an interesting approach: how educational institutions organize zombie apocalypses. This practice engages students and creates a unique learning environment. In such activities, participants can develop skills in teamwork, strategic thinking, and quick response to unconventional situations. Zombie apocalypses in schools and universities are becoming not only exciting entertainment but also an effective tool for developing leadership and communication skills in young people.

The key is to find not just any frame, but one that already offers a solution to your problem. Selecting the appropriate frame will save you time and effort while ensuring the effective achievement of your goals. Make sure the chosen frame meets your requirements and already has practical examples of solving similar problems.

Now it's important to extract from the identified frame specific tools that will help solve our problem. These tools can be actions, objects, forms of interaction, or integration that can be included in the educational program. Identifying these elements will allow you to effectively address the problem and improve the learning process.

Analyze the identified frame, paying attention to its roles, forms of interaction, and context. Using analogies, transfer these elements to your educational program. This will help you create a more effective and structured educational environment that meets modern requirements. By focusing on participant interaction and the learning context, you can improve the quality of the educational process and make it more accessible and understandable for everyone.

Let's say you have an online program for training programmers. One of the key challenges is that the traditional online course format is boring, and students lack a sense of connection and support from their peers, tutors, and faculty. When you asked yourself, "How can we make program participants feel a sense of their role and belonging?" you turned to the metaphor of a "soccer championship." Using this metaphor, you can consider several approaches to improving student interaction. For example, you could create teams where participants work on projects, like players on a soccer team. Each team could be assigned a captain to coordinate activities and maintain team spirit. Additionally, you could introduce elements of competition, such as problem-solving tournaments or hackathons where teams compete against each other. This will not only create healthy competition but also provide an opportunity for students to share knowledge and experiences.

It's also worth considering the possibility of regular videoconference meetings, where students can share their progress, discuss challenges, and receive feedback from instructors. This format of communication will help strengthen community and increase engagement.

By introducing elements of sports competition into online learning, you can significantly increase student motivation and create an atmosphere of collaboration, which will ultimately improve the quality of learning and programming achievement.

  • How would homework change if we had a neighborhood football championship program?
  • What form of interaction in the "Nearby Football Championship" situation resembles homework? For example, when participants spontaneously go out into the yard to play football and practice at the same time.
  • How might a similar situation look in our online programming training program? For example, a virtual "courtyard" could be Zoom, which "opens" every Thursday from 8:00 PM to 10:00 PM.

Now our student-players can use Zoom to collaborate on homework or practice coding. If someone logs into Zoom and can't find anyone from their group, they can easily ask a classmate: "Sergey, let's go on Zoom!" It's like inviting friends outside to play soccer, creating an atmosphere of collaboration and interaction.

Daria recommends using analogies and finding connections between educational subjects and activities using an artifact table or a learning story map. These tools will help better structure information and facilitate the learning process by identifying key elements and their interactions.

An artifact table is a visual aid for applying the CRAFT methodology. It allows you to extract specific ideas and concepts from the general context that can be used in educational programs. This tool helps structure information and streamline the process of developing learning materials, providing a more targeted and effective approach to learning.

This is what the artifact table looks like. To open the image in full size, follow the link. The format is suitable for printing. Illustration: Courtesy of the IKRA School of Innovation.

The Learning Story Map is a CRAFT/ED-adapted version of the well-known Student Journey Map, familiar to many methodologists and producers. This tool allows for visualization and analysis of student journeys, identifying key stages and interactions, thereby improving the educational process. Using a learning story map helps optimize curricula and improve the quality of teaching.

This is what a learning story map looks like. To open the image in full size, follow the link. Illustration: Courtesy of the IKRA School of Innovations.

Based on the given frame, a specific story is developed, which is then used to create educational activities. However, the story itself can be set aside and not discussed with students. In the given example, students are not informed about the "Street Football Championship" concept. They are only informed about the opportunity to participate in an open Zoom conference with their classmates on certain days. This approach allows students to focus on educational goals without being distracted by plot details.

It is important to evaluate the collected information from the perspective of didactic principles. It is necessary to determine which elements correspond to the rules of effective learning and which do not. If contradictions are identified, it is worth considering ways to resolve them to create a more harmonious learning environment.

It is necessary to integrate new ideas and mechanics into the educational process in a way that aligns with learning outcomes. Sometimes tools, such as tests, may not be compatible with the overall concept of the course. This limitation should be taken into account, and carefully considered how to present it within a course to ensure maximum learning effectiveness, notes Daria Savelyeva, co-author of the CRAFT/ED methodology. The process of applying the CRAFT/ED method may seem complex and time-consuming, but in practice, it proves to be quick and effective. Anna Krylova, a methodologist at Skillbox and experienced with this approach, notes: "In reality, we simply brainstorm, generate creative ideas, and then, taking into account the initial data, select the most suitable options. CRAFT/ED offers useful filters for this process, simplifying the selection process. It's important to note that some steps can be combined. If you already have a good understanding of your course's target audience, key objectives, and methodological constraints, you can immediately filter ideas as they arise." Using the CRAFT/ED method allows you to more effectively structure ideas and adapt them to specific goals, which significantly accelerates the process of developing educational programs.

A branched quest is an innovative method that makes learning more engaging and interactive. It includes game elements, allowing participants to choose different paths, which contributes to a deeper assimilation of the material. The use of branched quests in the educational process not only stimulates interest in the topics studied, but also develops critical thinking, creativity, and teamwork. The introduction of such approaches into teaching helps improve student motivation and enhance the quality of information assimilation.

An example of using CRAFT/ED in course development

CRAFT/ED used an experimental approach when creating the Skillbox course "Marketing Director." The method made it possible to develop a role-based model of the course, while taking into account classic audience research that identified its needs and characteristics. The course is aimed not at beginners, but at experienced professionals over 30 years old. The research found that this audience is looking for in-depth knowledge and practical skills that will help them advance their careers and reach new heights in marketing.

  • they often experience impostor syndrome;
  • they may have a good foundation in hard skills in marketing, but at the same time there may be a deficit in soft skills - emotional intelligence, self-presentation, the ability to delicately give feedback, management skills.

Anna Krylova shared the solutions that were developed for this course using the CRAFT/ED platform. These solutions are aimed at improving the educational process and optimizing learning materials. CRAFT/ED allows you to tailor content to the needs of students, ensuring a deeper understanding of topics and effective knowledge acquisition.

We started with the abstract concept of "world" "And we detailed it in the context of both society's and the individual's life trajectory," explains Anna. "As a result, we identified three key areas that shape life trajectories: educational, personal, and career. Each of these areas is broken down into specific blocks. The personal area includes aspects such as family and friends. The educational area encompasses university education, on-the-job training, conference participation, reading books, and taking courses. Each of these blocks can also be further broken down into smaller elements. For example, within a conference, we consider various events such as personal presentations, listening to expert presentations, and opportunities to meet colleagues. This analysis allowed us to select activities for the course that take into account students' life experiences in situations familiar to them. A university education is viewed as an important value, and the university admissions process is competitive. When an applicant successfully passes this stage, they experience joy and pride: "Hurray, my level of knowledge turned out to be worthy, my efforts and preparation were not in vain, I made it!" This sense of achievement plays a key role in motivating students and building their self-confidence.

The idea of ​​holding a competitive selection of students for the course arose from a familiar university framework. Successfully completing this selection process allows applicants to recognize their value as specialists, which is especially important in the context of impostor syndrome. This approach also emphasizes the significance of the course, creating additional motivation for learning, notes Anna.

Competitive selection was in line with the interests of the educational platform, as ensuring an individual approach to each student requires creating limited streams and dividing them into mini-groups. This allows for more efficient organization of training and improves the quality of interaction between teachers and students.

We noted the problem of a lack of soft skills among our target audience and considered the situations in which these skills can be effectively developed. As Anna Krylova notes, professional conferences and meetups are among the best places for this. At such events, participants need to be able not only to present but also to argue their point of view in the event of a dispute, as well as to establish contacts with professionals in their field. Developing soft skills in such an environment promotes personal and career growth and improves teamwork.

As part of the course, we simulated a conference situation by organizing the defense of study projects. The program was divided into four thematic blocks, at the end of each of which students completed assignments and presented the results in the form of marketing strategies. We organized this process in the format of a discussion, involving course experts and students from other groups. Students had to defend their point of view, which reflects the real practice of developing marketing strategies, which always includes discussions and debates. This approach not only develops presentation skills, but also promotes a deep understanding of the processes taking place in marketing.

Working groups were formed on the basis of preliminary testing of students according to the Adizes typology, which ensured a targeted approach to team building. In each group, roles were defined, such as "manager", "executor", "creator" and "co-creator". and others, which made it possible to create mini-marketing departments. Team members periodically swapped roles, providing each participant with the opportunity to try their hand at leadership. This approach contributed to the development of managerial "soft skills" necessary for successful teamwork and marketing.

As part of the "Marketing Director" course, a new creative solution was developed for a workshop on creative strategy. This solution is aimed at deepening the participants' understanding of creating effective marketing campaigns and implementing innovative approaches to brand strategy.

Anna Krylova shares her experience organizing the workshop with the expert who was scheduled to lead the event. During the planning process, it became clear that it was necessary to take the students out of their usual work environment. Otherwise, they would continue to dwell on solutions they already knew, since they were all experienced marketers. The main problem is that high professional responsibility for the results of strategies significantly hinders creative thinking. Fear of failure creates barriers to innovation and new approaches. It's important to create an atmosphere where participants can freely experiment and generate unconventional ideas, allowing them to develop their skills and find new solutions.

How can we help course participants detach from their work experiences and discover bold, creative solutions? The answer lay in a seemingly unusual idea: using Russian folk tales as case studies instead of traditional business problems. The absence of traditional barriers allows people to express their creativity and come up with far more innovative solutions than would otherwise be possible in a typical work environment. This approach fosters innovative thinking and the ability to view problems from a new perspective.

The Frog Princess strives for her business goal—to become human. The instructor emphasizes that she has her own tools for achieving this goal: she knows how to bake bread, weave carpets, and perform other crafts. Students must develop a strategy to help the Frog Princess convey to Ivan Tsarevich the need to transform her into a human. It is important to analyze how to use her skills and resources to achieve this goal.

A variety of well-known fairy tale plots were collected on the "Mountain of Ideas" and served as the basis for further analysis in the "Reflection Field." Workshop participants explored which of these plots most effectively met the objectives and how to adapt them for all stages of creating a communications strategy. This approach allows for the integration of fairy tale elements into strategic planning, which contributes to a deeper understanding of communications aspects and enhances creativity in the strategy development process.

Anna shares her impressions of how this unusual solution turned out to be successful: "At first, the students were skeptical of the idea: 'Practice on fairy tales? That's not serious!'" However, during the process, a real explosion of imagination occurred! Using fairy tales gave them a sense of freedom: in this form, any idea could be realized. This approach significantly expanded their horizons of possibilities. Most importantly, this experience paved the way for true creativity in real-life work situations. The students overcame their fear of choice and began to make unconventional decisions, rather than repeating tried and tested approaches. Now they are not afraid to experiment in their professional activities.»

Read also:

  • Unusual practice: how a teacher turned history lessons into detective stories
  • Storytelling in education: a trendy thing or a useful thing?
  • How to motivate students to complete a course using emotions
  • What is a Learning Journey Map and how to use this tool