Education

Higher or Secondary? Which Education Do Graduates Choose?

Higher or Secondary? Which Education Do Graduates Choose?

Skillbox Digital College → In-demand professions in IT and design. Application deadline: June 20 – August 15.

Learn more

According to annual surveys, admissions campaign results, and scientific research, the number of Russian high school graduates entering college has been growing over the past decade. This trend is driven by a multitude of interrelated factors that influence the choice of educational path.

In this article, you will learn about SEO and how it affects website promotion. You will also learn about the key factors that contribute to improving your resource's visibility in search engines. Learn how to optimize your website's content and structure to achieve better search results. Understanding the basic principles of SEO will help you attract your target audience and increase traffic to your website.

  • How many applicants choose secondary vocational education?
  • How did the introduction of the mandatory Unified State Exam affect the fate of graduates of the 2010s?
  • Can the growing popularity of secondary vocational education be linked to the falling economic returns from higher education?
  • What are the main factors in the growth of college enrollments?

Statistics prove: demand for secondary vocational education is growing

In a recent study conducted by researchers from the Institute of Education at the Higher School of Economics, Vera Maltseva and Alexey Shabalin analyzed the number of applicants and graduates in higher education institutions and the secondary vocational education system for the period from 2005 to 2020. The study was based on annual federal statistical surveys and demographic statistics from Rosstat. The study's key finding indicates that incoming student flows began shifting from universities to secondary vocational education as early as the mid-2010s. This trend highlights changing applicant preferences and may indicate the growing popularity of secondary vocational education as an alternative to traditional higher education.

The popularity of specialized vocational education (SVE) programs is observed primarily among those programs that train mid-level specialists. At the same time, demand for programs training skilled workers and employees continues to slowly but steadily decline. This indicates changing labor market needs and applicant preferences.

The two types of educational programs in the field of medicine differ in duration, applicant requirements, and the qualifications they provide. For example, after completing 11th grade, applicants can take a training course for junior nurses, which lasts only ten months and is classified as skilled workers. At the same time, obtaining a mid-level specialist diploma in Nursing requires at least two years and ten months of study. These differences are important to consider when choosing an educational path in healthcare.

A study of youth enrollment in vocational education programs showed that a significant proportion of young people aged 15 to 25 are studying at colleges and universities or already have a diploma. For programs training skilled workers and employees (SWE), the typical age of study is 15–17 years, and for mid-level specialist training (MLS), it is 15–19 years. Bachelor's and specialist's degree programs begin at age 17 and continue until age 25. Analysis of data over the past 15 years demonstrates that enrollment in the secondary vocational education (SVE) system has increased significantly, while the proportion of young people with higher education has decreased slightly. This indicates a change in educational preferences among young people and possible trends in the labor market.

Data source: Maltseva V. A., Shabalin A. I. A non-workaround, or a boom in demand for secondary vocational education in Russia // Educational Studies Moscow. 2021, No. 2, p. 18. Illustration: Skillbox Media.

The results of the annual admissions campaigns confirm the growing interest in mid-level specialist training programs. In 2020, the number of applicants to these programs exceeded the number of those wishing to study for bachelor's and specialist degrees for the first time: 900,000 versus 873,000. In addition, 214,000 people were enrolled in blue-collar and white-collar training programs. This trend indicates a significant increase in interest in vocational education and may indicate changes in labor market needs.

Since 2005, there has been an increase in the number of 9th and 11th grade graduates choosing secondary vocational education. According to the data presented, the share of students entering mid-level specialist training programs has increased over ten years from 25.5% to 38% of 9th-grade graduates. This trend indicates the growing popularity of secondary vocational education as an alternative to traditional higher education.

Data source: Maltseva V. A., Shabalin A. I. A non-bypass maneuver, or a boom in demand for secondary vocational education in Russia // Educational Studies Moscow. 2021. No. 2. P. 20. Illustration: Skillbox Media

In 2020, 67.1% of 11th-grade graduates continued their education at universities. However, there has been a noticeable increase in the number of those choosing secondary vocational education (SVE). The share of students entering SVE increased from 12.7% in 2012 to 20.6% in 2020. This indicates a growing interest in vocational specialties and alternative educational paths among young people.

How research explains the popularity of SVE

Many factors influence the increase in the number of applications for secondary vocational education (SVE) programs. There are several common hypotheses explaining this trend. Firstly, increased interest in practical skills and specialties in demand on the labor market is contributing to an increase in student enrollment. Secondly, active collaboration between educational institutions and employers allows for the creation of relevant educational programs that meet modern requirements. Also worth noting is the influence of information technology and the availability of online courses, which makes education more flexible and accessible. Overall, these factors are driving growing interest in vocational education programs and promoting their popularity among young people.

The introduction of the mandatory Unified State Exam (USE) has led to increased selection in high school. Proponents of this hypothesis note that educational institutions seek to avoid the problems associated with low USE scores. As a result, schools focus on graduating students with higher achievement levels, which leads to the elimination of students with insufficient preparation. This process occurs both through formal selection and due to the reluctance of students themselves and their parents to invest time and resources in preparing for the exam, as well as to deal with the stress associated with it. Thus, the USE significantly influences educational processes and the choice of teaching strategies in Russian schools.

Preparing students for the USE is an important task for every teacher. Effective preparation of students can significantly improve their confidence and exam performance. To achieve this goal, it is necessary to use a variety of motivational and support methods. It is important to create a positive atmosphere where students feel confident and prepared for challenges. Additionally, it's worth focusing on practicing the skills needed to successfully pass the Unified State Exam and regular testing, which will help students better navigate the exam format. Use a variety of resources and strategies to make the preparation process engaging and productive. Read also: How a teacher can prepare children for the Unified State Exam.

Research shows the influence of "push" factors on the educational process. According to data from experts at the HSE Institute of Education, from 2000 to 2015, the proportion of ninth-grade graduates continuing their education in secondary school decreased by almost 12 percentage points. This indicates that the transition to high school has become more challenging and requires additional efforts from students and educational institutions.

The popularity of secondary vocational education (SVE) is explained not only by its accessibility. As experts Maltseva and Shabalin note, many eleventh-grade graduates choose colleges despite having already passed the Unified State Exam and could have entered universities. This indicates that the university path is uninteresting or inaccessible to them for reasons unrelated to the educational system. Thus, the choice of secondary vocational education may be driven by various factors, including career preferences, financial considerations, or personal circumstances.

Entering a college is often seen as an alternative path to university. The main reason is that passing the Unified State Exam (USE) is challenging, and competition for state-funded places in popular university programs is fierce. There is a risk of not achieving the required score and ultimately being left without the opportunity to continue education. Enrolling in a secondary vocational education (SVE) program after 9th grade helps minimize these risks and opens new prospects for obtaining a qualification and further study at a university.

Applicants with a secondary vocational education (SVE) diploma do not take the Unified State Exam (USE), but take internal entrance exams at universities. These exams are generally less difficult. Even if you fail to secure a state-funded place, having a profession allows you to start a career and work in your field. This provides the opportunity to gain practical experience and develop your skills, which can be useful for future education or professional development.

There is data confirming the importance of this alternative pathway at the national level. According to the 2015 Monitoring of Education Economics report, 60% of students enrolled in mid-level specialist training programs planned to enroll in universities after graduation. Moreover, the majority of them intended to work simultaneously. This underscores the relevance and demand for educational programs that allow you to combine study and work, which in turn facilitates the successful integration of young people into the labor market and the professional development of specialists.

Not all graduates realize their plans to enroll in higher education. According to Deputy Minister of Education Dmitry Glushko, in 2020, only 12% of students who graduated from colleges that year entered universities. Maltseva and Shabalin, relying on federal statistics, estimate this figure to be higher. However, they also do not believe that for most students in secondary vocational education (SVE), university admission is simply a ploy to obtain higher education. The researchers note that this "transitional trajectory" is primarily chosen by graduates of specialized colleges at universities where the process for admission to bachelor's programs after SVE completion is well-established. This underscores the importance of adapting the education system to the needs of students and creating more accessible pathways for continuing education.

Data source: Maltseva V. A., Shabalin A. I. A non-bypass maneuver, or a boom in demand for secondary vocational education in Russia // Educational Studies Moscow. 2021. No. 2. P. 21. Illustration: Skillbox Media

College graduates sometimes take a break from their studies to serve in the military, start a family, or start a career before enrolling in university as they originally planned. While such cases exist, they are not widespread. Research by Maltseva and Shabalin showed that since 2015, the share of students entering universities with secondary vocational education diplomas has remained stable at 35%. This figure indicates that the majority of college graduates continue to follow the traditional path to higher education.

While many professions require a college degree, there are many modern specialties, especially in the digital sector, where one can successfully work without a university degree. This opens up new opportunities for job seekers looking to develop careers in fields such as IT, marketing, and design. It's important to note that practical skills and experience are often valued more highly than formal education, allowing many people to realize their potential and achieve success without a traditional degree. A college degree is not always a guarantee of job satisfaction. Many graduates struggle to find suitable employment, even with a degree. Often, having a degree doesn't guarantee a person will find their ideal career or be satisfied with their professional life. It's important to understand that success in the labor market depends on many factors, including personal qualities, skills, experience, and adaptability. Therefore, even with a college degree, it's important to develop soft skills and actively seek out career opportunities. Schoolchildren's educational plans change over time. According to a survey conducted by the educational company Maximum Education in May 2021, 60% of parents of students in grades 5-11 expected their children to attend university. Meanwhile, another survey conducted by the recruiting platform SuperJob found that only 43% of parents of eleventh-graders plan for their children to attend university. Interestingly, SuperJob conducts this survey annually, and since 2010, the number of parents wanting their children to attend university has almost halved. These data highlight significant shifts in perceptions of higher education and its importance for the future of young people.

Some studies indicate a decline in interest in higher education, linking this to its economic disadvantage. Experts in the field of human capital evaluate the effectiveness of education by analyzing its return on investment. To do this, they compare the earnings of representatives of the same generation and the same professional field with different levels of education. If an employee with a university degree earns 80% more than their colleagues without a higher education, then it can be argued that the return on higher education accounts for this 80% of their income. Thus, the economic value of higher education continues to be a relevant topic of discussion.

Scientists often analyze the economic return on each additional year of education, rather than assessing the overall benefits of obtaining a degree. This allows them to more accurately determine the impact of education on career advancement and income. Research shows that each year of education can significantly increase earnings and improve professional prospects.

According to a 2018 World Bank study, on average, a year of education increases wages by 8-9% worldwide. Higher education brings an even larger increase - 15%. In Russia, the situation is different: a year of any education increases income by only 5.6%, while higher education provides an increase of only 8%. These data demonstrate the low returns to education in our country, significantly lower than the global average.

The study showed that the returns to education in Russia began to decline as early as the 2000s. This World Bank data was widely disseminated in the Russian media and recognized by many researchers. As a result, the term "the curse of the educated Russian" emerged, denoting that investing in one's own education in our country does not yield the expected benefits. This phenomenon is concerning, as education is traditionally considered an important factor for personal and economic growth. A decline in returns to education could negatively impact the skill level of the workforce and, consequently, the country's global competitiveness.

In 2021, Rostislav Kapelyushnikov, Deputy Director of the Center for Labor Studies at the Higher School of Economics and Corresponding Member of the Russian Academy of Sciences, presented an alternative perspective on the World Bank's calculated returns to education. According to him, the figure of 5.6% may be incorrect. Kapelyushnikov emphasizes the importance of a more in-depth analysis of the factors influencing the economic efficiency of education and proposes revising the calculation methodology to obtain more accurate data on the impact of education on economic growth.

In his preprint posted on the Higher School of Economics website, Kapelyushnikov notes that the World Bank researchers' conclusions are based on data from a single source—the Russian Longitudinal Monitoring Survey (RLMS). This emphasizes the importance of using a variety of data for more accurate analysis and the formulation of recommendations in the areas of healthcare and the economy.

RLMS is an annual survey organized by the Higher School of Economics since 1994. The study is conducted on a permanent sample of households in 35 regions of Russia, which allows for the analysis of changes in the economic situation over many years. Despite its valuable data source, the survey has certain limitations. The sample includes only five thousand families, which may not fully reflect the situation in the country. It's also worth keeping in mind that data on respondents' incomes are presented monthly, which may bias the results due to random fluctuations.

In his work, Kapelyushnikov estimated the returns to education in Russia for the same period as the World Bank researchers, using more extensive databases. He used data from the Occupational Wage Survey (OZPP), the Sample Survey of Daily Time Use by Population (VNISFT), and the Sample Survey of Population Income and Participation in Social Programs (VNDN). All of these studies are conducted by Rosstat and have their limitations: they began significantly later than the RLMS, and only the VNDN is conducted annually, while data from the other two sources is collected less frequently. Thus, Kapelyushnikov proposed an alternative approach to analyzing the impact of education on economic indicators, which may be useful for further research in this area.

According to research sources, Russia has not seen declining returns to education. Each additional year of education increases Russians' income by 12-13% per year, and a higher education can lead to a salary increase of up to 25%. This underscores the importance of investing in education to improve citizens' financial well-being. Rostislav Kapelyushnikov argues that the economic attractiveness of higher education in Russia remains high. The decline in demand for higher education is not due to a decrease in its benefits, but is due to other factors. This underscores the importance of analyzing the labor market and employer needs, which can influence the choice of educational programs. In the face of economic and technological changes, higher education continues to be a valuable asset, opening new career opportunities and promoting personal development. The decline in demand for higher education may be due not so much to a decrease in its benefits as to an increase in its costs. This is due not so much to negative changes in the structure of relative earnings, but to the growing financial and non-financial burden on students and their families. With rising tuition fees and additional expenses associated with the educational process, many potential students may reconsider their priorities and forgo higher education.

The hypothesis of growing demand for secondary vocational education (SVE) due to the declining availability of higher education for economic reasons has been discussed by researchers for a long time. Vera Maltseva and Alexey Shabalin believe this point of view is the most substantiated. Given the current economic realities, more and more people are considering SVE as a worthy alternative to higher education, which confirms the trend of increasing numbers of applicants to vocational educational institutions.

It seems paradoxical to discuss the inaccessibility of higher education in a context where the number of state-funded places at universities, especially in the regions, is constantly increasing.

The network of colleges and technical schools is much wider than the number of universities, making obtaining a secondary vocational education more accessible for graduates from small towns. College education is often less expensive and does not require relocation. Furthermore, students can begin working in their field immediately after completing their studies, allowing them to quickly enter the workforce and begin earning money. This is especially important for those who want to avoid long years of university study without employment opportunities.

Maltseva and Shabalin emphasize that in the 2010s, the number of families for whom economic considerations became key when choosing an education increased. Even families with relatively high incomes increasingly perceive higher education as a financial burden for their children. In 2013, only 31% of students in secondary vocational education (SVE) belonged to the wealthiest groups (the 4th and 5th quintiles). However, by 2017, this figure had risen to 52%, indicating significant changes in the perception of the cost of education and its accessibility for different segments of the population.

Expert opinion confirms the growing interest in the secondary vocational education (SVE) system after 9th grade. Tatyana Klyachko, Director of the Center for Continuous Education Economics at the Institute of Applied Economic Research at RANEPA, highlighted the key factors driving this trend in an interview on the RANEPA website. She noted that students are increasingly choosing SVE, seeking practical skills and more quickly adapting to labor market demands. This not only enhances graduates' competitiveness but also meets employers' needs for qualified personnel. Thus, transitioning to SVE is becoming an important step for young people striving for a successful career.

Uncertainty about the future is increasing, and family incomes are declining. In these circumstances, parents are eager for their children to begin working and earning money as soon as possible. The deteriorating economic situation is causing more and more families to question the feasibility of long-term education planning, which includes two years of high school, four years of a bachelor's degree, and two years of a master's degree. This necessitates adapting educational strategies and considering alternative pathways to professional growth.

A recent sociological survey conducted by researchers at the Center for Continuous Education Economics at RANEPA confirmed that graduates choose secondary vocational education (SVE) primarily for economic reasons. The study included 903 respondents from the Sverdlovsk, Samara, and Volgograd regions, who were studying in a SVE program or already had a diploma. The study's authors identified three key factors in choosing SVE: the desire to quickly enter the labor market, successful employment, and the possibility of earning a high salary. These results underscore the importance of SVE as an effective path to career advancement and financial stability.

Research shows that the level of a region's socioeconomic development directly influences respondents' career choices. In low-income regions, short-term economic motives become key. The opportunity to enter the labor market and begin earning money in the near future proves to be a decisive factor for these respondents. Conversely, in more prosperous regions, such as the Sverdlovsk Region, the importance of professional prestige increases. 59% of respondents from this region noted that when choosing a specialty in secondary vocational education, they were guided by the prestige of the profession. Thus, socioeconomic conditions significantly influence preferences and motivations when choosing an educational path. Applicants from less prosperous regions are more likely to enroll in colleges. This is due to the fact that access to quality education may be limited in these regions. Young people from these regions seek higher education to improve their life prospects and social status. Education becomes an important tool for them to achieve success and overcome difficult situations. These trends highlight the importance of investing in education and supporting young people in difficult circumstances, which can contribute to the development of the region as a whole.

Why the SVE System Needs Change

Academic science has yet to study one important factor in the growth of secondary vocational education (SVE)—it is possible that colleges themselves are becoming more attractive. This opinion is supported by the positive information background created by the WorldSkills movement around SVE. Maltseva and Shabalin note that these competitions have become an effective tool for the development of secondary vocational education in Russia. New industry standards are being introduced, demonstration exams are actively practiced, and teacher retraining is carried out. These changes are contributing to increased interest in colleges and improving the quality of specialist training, which, in turn, contributes to the growing popularity of SVE among young people.

Currently, there are no studies confirming a connection between the updated image of secondary vocational education (SVE) and the increase in the number of applicants. Nevertheless, this connection appears logical. If secondary vocational education becomes more modern, high-quality, and prestigious, then choosing a college is not seen as a rejection of higher education. It becomes a conscious and independent choice of educational trajectory. This approach allows applicants to acquire in-demand skills that meet the current demands of the labor market.

The secondary vocational education system still does not demonstrate sufficient flexibility in response to growing demand, note experts Maltseva and Shabalin. It appears unprepared for its popularity, which limits its potential and ability to adapt to new market conditions.

Colleges in Russia are primarily aimed at ninth-grade graduates, offering them the opportunity to replace high school and exercise their constitutional right to free secondary education. In the 2010s, budget-funded places in the secondary vocational education (SVE) system for eleventh-grade graduates were allocated primarily on a residual basis, which led to increased competition for admission to popular specialties. Thus, access to colleges has become limited, and the pathway to secondary vocational education is no longer barrier-free. Despite the right to free secondary vocational education enshrined in the Constitution of the Russian Federation, the system is seeing an increase in the number of fee-based places, calling into question the accessibility of education for all categories of citizens.

Significant changes are currently underway in secondary vocational education. An experiment to introduce professionalism is being launched, educational standards are being updated, and new types of educational institutions are opening in major cities. These transformations could become a turning point for the secondary vocational education system, allowing quantitative growth to translate into qualitative development and the dissemination of successful practices throughout the country.

To effectively promote your content in search engines, it is important to consider keywords and phrases. Optimized text should not only be informative but also easy for readers to understand.

Regular content updates help keep information current and improve search rankings. The use of internal and external links also helps increase the authority of your resource.

Don't forget about meta tags and headings, which play a crucial role in SEO. Proper text structuring and the use of subheadings will help users find the information they need faster.

Write unique and valuable content that answers your audience's questions. This will not only attract new readers but also retain their attention.

Keep an eye on changes in search engine algorithms and adapt your SEO strategy accordingly to stay afloat in the ever-changing digital world.

  • What's wrong with general education in secondary vocational education?
  • Will higher education lose out to vocational courses?
  • How much do tutors cost Russian families?