Education

How can we make university admissions more fair? There's an idea – a contextual approach

How can we make university admissions more fair? There's an idea – a contextual approach

Learn: Educational Methodist

Learn more

The US university admissions system differs significantly from the Russian one, but there are also a number of common features. In both countries, admission to educational institutions is competitive, and universities accept the best students based on their level of preparation. In Russia, this rule applies to admission to state-funded places, with the exception of preferential categories. Furthermore, both systems have been criticized for unequal access to education: applicants from families with high socioeconomic status often have an advantage, despite formally equal opportunities. This creates inequality in educational opportunities and requires attention from educational institutions and government agencies.

In the US, one approach to addressing inequality is contextual assessment. This method assumes that admissions committees should consider the achievements of each applicant in the context of their life circumstances and opportunities. Achievements that may seem insignificant compared to the successes of other candidates may be the result of maximum effort in difficult circumstances. If an applicant has achieved significant results in a limited environment, this demonstrates their potential. Thus, contextual assessment helps identify talented students who deserve a place at higher education institutions despite external constraints.

Applicants should be considered not only through the prism of their scores, but also through a deeper analysis of their abilities and potential. Comparing scores alone does not always provide a complete picture of a candidate. It is important to consider individual qualities, experience, and motivation, which can significantly impact academic and career success. This approach will allow for a more objective assessment of candidates and select those who are truly capable of excelling in their chosen field.

This method, like many other ideas, has raised doubts and criticism. Nevertheless, some universities have already begun implementing it, and researchers are actively researching its effectiveness. In this article, we will take a closer look at this approach and its potential in the field of education.

How Inequality Manifests in College Admissions

In the United States, barriers to higher education are not limited to cost. While scholarships and grants are available to those in need, obtaining them requires successfully passing a competitive selection process, which often poses a challenge for youth from socially disadvantaged and low-income families. These applicants typically face difficulties due to a lack of resources and opportunities enjoyed by their more affluent peers. Children from wealthy families have access to high-quality educational institutions and extracurricular activities from an early age, making them better prepared for college. Thus, the gap in educational opportunities between different social groups persists, hindering equal access to higher education.

In the United States, the problem of racial inequality in education manifests itself through the underrepresentation of Black and Latino students in universities, especially at the most prestigious institutions. This is due to the fact that these groups often experience worse socioeconomic conditions than white Americans. Long-term discrimination and unequal access to quality education exacerbate this situation, resulting in a lack of opportunities for young people from these communities. It is important to understand that solving this problem requires a comprehensive approach aimed at eliminating systemic barriers and creating equal conditions for all students.

Still: film "Future War" / Skydance Media / Paramount Pictures

The United States lacks a unified system for admission to state-funded places, allowing universities and colleges to independently establish their own admissions policies and determine the number of students accepted. The selection process often appears "black box," but it is competitive in any case, as educational institutions strive to select the best applicants. Some universities consider the results of standardized tests such as the ACT and SAT, which are analogous to our Unified State Exam, while others do not. Admissions committees also pay attention to the applicant's school portfolio, including high school GPA and the completion of difficult advanced courses, which are usually optional. In addition, participation in competitions and projects outside of the classroom is an important factor, which can significantly increase the chances of admission.

The social lottery is most often won by those who find themselves in more privileged circumstances. For example, a young person from an affluent family, living in a prestigious neighborhood, and attending a top public or expensive private school has a significant advantage in preparation compared to someone from a poor family who attended a school in a disadvantaged neighborhood. It's no coincidence that the former performs better on tests, has higher academic performance, and has a more rigorous selection of courses in high school, including courses that may be lacking at less affluent schools. Furthermore, they are more likely to participate in competitions and other activities, which further contributes to their success.

In the Russian socioeconomic context, family financial status and education level play a significant role. Young people from affluent and highly educated families living in large cities have significantly better chances of entering universities, especially prestigious and highly selective ones. In contrast, young people from low-income families, those with parents with limited education, and those from small towns and villages face greater difficulties in entering higher education. This creates inequality in educational opportunities and highlights the influence of socioeconomic status on the future of young people in Russia.

Analysts from the HSE Institute of Education have found that teenagers from low-income families, where parents lack higher education, and who live in small towns are more likely to choose colleges and technical schools after 9th grade. This indicates that they are less likely to pursue higher education. Moreover, at the most prestigious universities, over 60% of students come from high-income families, while the share of students from the poorest groups is only 5%. At less prestigious institutions, the percentage of students from low-income families is twice as high. The differences in educational opportunities between children from affluent families and their peers from less affluent backgrounds are rooted in more than just financial means. Children from wealthy families have access to fee-paying university education if they do not qualify for state-funded places. However, both routes to free places—through the Unified State Exam and Olympiads—require significant preparation, which is often unavailable in a regular school. High-income parents provide their children with better conditions to prepare for admission, including choosing higher-quality schools, hiring tutors, and participating in extracurricular activities from an early age. Large cities offer more opportunities and options for obtaining a quality education, while smaller towns may have only one school, often with a shortage of qualified teachers. This creates a significant gap in the chances of successful admission to universities.

Still: film "To Each His Own" / Annapurna Pictures / Detour Filmproduction

Educational inequality is not only a financial issue. Parents' education level also plays a significant role. More educated parents motivate their children to attend prestigious universities from an early age, devote time and effort to additional education, understand the importance of school choice, and may decide to move to attend a quality educational institution. Thus, parents' education level directly impacts their children's academic and career success and prospects.

High Unified State Exam (USE) scores are often the result not only of a student's personal efforts but also of family support, a quality education at school, and financial resources. Preparing for Olympiads, in particular, is a serious and costly process. A child from a disadvantaged family, especially in remote areas, often finds it difficult to cope with such tasks without adult support.

A teenager who received high USE scores and additional points for individual achievements does not always possess greater abilities than a peer with lower results and no individual achievements. Often, differences in success are due to living conditions and available opportunities. Thus, in the overall competition based on scores, the teenager with the highest score has an advantage and can enter a university, while his peer with lower scores is left behind. This underscores the importance of equal access to educational resources and opportunities for all students, regardless of their initial circumstances.

How the US tried to solve the problem with racial quotas

Most recently, the US tried to address the problem of educational inequality associated with racial and socioeconomic factors through a quota system. This system provided benefits to representatives of racial minorities. Although race was supposed to be taken into account not alone, but in addition to basic criteria such as test scores, grade point averages, and portfolios, this still raised many questions. Is it fair to deny one promising young person a place at an educational institution to another based solely on the color of their skin? This issue remains relevant and requires in-depth analysis and debate.

In 2023, a landmark event occurred in American education: the US Supreme Court ruled that the policy of providing special privileges to Black and Latino applicants was unlawful. The lawsuit, filed by the non-profit advocacy organization Students for Fair Admissions (SFFA), was directed against Harvard College and the University of North Carolina. The advocates argued that race should not be considered in the admissions process, as it leads to discrimination against other applicants. The Supreme Court's decision underscores the importance of equal access to education for everyone, regardless of race, and could significantly change admissions practices at US higher education institutions.

The Supreme Court's decision does not address the underlying problem that led to the introduction of racial quotas. First, quotas ineffectively address the root causes of inequality in educational admissions. Many Black and Latino students face disadvantaged social and financial circumstances, making it difficult for them to succeed academically. For example, according to The Guardian, in North Carolina, Black people make up 21% of the population, but at the local university, they represent only 8%. This shows that even with racial quotas in place, access to higher education remains limited for a significant number of these groups.

Still: film "Women's Rise" / Vulcan Productions / The Documentary Group

Now that the Supreme Court has overturned even this, albeit imperfect, remedy for inequality, the number of racial minority students in higher education may decline significantly. This raises serious concerns and raises the question of possible alternatives. What measures can be taken to improve the situation and ensure equal access to education for all? New approaches must be sought that will help create a system that embraces diversity and provides fair opportunities for all students, regardless of race.

What is contextual assessment?

The concept of contextual assessment in admissions is actively discussed and already being applied in the United States. The basic idea is to go beyond ranking indicators such as test scores, GPA, and the number of additional courses. Instead, it is important to consider the context of each candidate. This means that an applicant's performance should be compared not only to general standards, but also to the results of other graduates from his or her school, and in some cases, to the indicators of the entire district or city. This approach provides a more complete picture of the abilities and achievements of each student, which can lead to a fairer and more justified admissions process.

Proponents of this approach believe that it provides an opportunity to objectively evaluate a student's achievements, taking into account the specific socioeconomic conditions in which he or she finds himself or herself. This analysis allows for a more accurate understanding of how various factors influence a child's educational outcomes and development. For example, suppose a young person has a lower GPA than other university applicants. However, this GPA is significantly higher than the average for their school and even their district. This suggests that they were among the most talented and motivated students at their school. Had they attended a stronger school, they likely would have achieved results as high as their more successful peers. Furthermore, if their school did not offer advanced courses, comparing their portfolio with other applicants who did is unfair. This underscores the importance of considering the context of the educational environment when evaluating student achievement. This approach helps to objectively assess the true potential of each applicant. If a candidate maximizes the resources and opportunities available to them, this demonstrates their determination and motivation. However, it is important to keep in mind that each individual has a different level of available opportunities, making comparisons between applicants difficult. Potential assessments must take into account the individual circumstances in which each candidate developed.

Studies such as this and this have confirmed that using this approach significantly increases the likelihood of admission for applicants from socioeconomically disadvantaged backgrounds compared to traditional selection methods. This approach creates a more equal playing field for all candidates, which contributes to social justice in the educational sphere.

There are concerns about the success of students admitted based on their context. The question is whether they will be able to cope with the academic workload and whether they will be among those who quickly leave the university due to insufficient preparation. Objectively, they will be studying alongside classmates with a higher level of knowledge and skills. This may create additional difficulties and affect their academic performance.

A large study was recently conducted in which researchers sought to understand these issues. The study covers a variety of aspects and provides valuable data for further analysis.

How the Study Was Conducted

Researchers from the University of Michigan and the University of North Carolina analyzed data obtained from the department of education in an undisclosed midwestern state. As part of the study, they examined three large data sources for the period from 2010 to 2015, which allowed them to identify important trends and patterns in the region's education system. This study may have a significant impact on further education reforms and on making informed decisions to improve the quality of education.

  • data from all public high schools in the state;
  • the ACT test database (analogous to the Unified State Exam) for the state;
  • data from 15 public universities in the state during the period.

The researchers chose this state because the ACT test was required for all high school graduates during the specified period. This allowed us to objectively analyze test results in the relevant context and conduct a more in-depth assessment of educational achievement.

Based on the analysis of data from more than 2.3 million high school graduates, a final sample was formed. This sample included 77,804 high school seniors who became college students. Information about them was sufficiently complete, which allowed us to compare their academic performance in school and university, taking into account various contextual factors.

The study took into account data on the race of young people, their place of residence (urban, suburban, rural), and financial situation. This made it possible to determine the eligibility for a Pell Grant - federal financial aid for students from low-income families. In the sample, it was found that 27.7% of young people could count on this support. In addition, the characteristics of educational institutions were analyzed, including school level, the percentage of students from racial minorities, and the proportion of students receiving free or reduced-price lunches. These parameters help to better understand the educational environment in which each respondent studied.

Still: film "Step by Step" / A.K. Worldwide Productions / Alloy Entertainment

This extensive dataset allowed us to create a contextual assessment model that was tested on real students. We were able to analyze how young people with different school records and sociodemographic characteristics studied in college. This study makes it possible to identify patterns and predict academic success based on previous data, which is important for improving educational processes and adapting curricula.

The researchers examined the relationship between student success indicators in school and their academic achievement in college. The study focused on such parameters as contextual school performance, ACT test scores, and information about the completion of advanced courses. The main question was to what extent these contextual indicators can serve as a reliable indicator of an applicant's potential for success in college. The results of the study will help better understand how school achievements influence subsequent academic careers and whether it is worth relying on these indicators in student admissions.

Scientists are particularly interested in the indicator associated with studying the most difficult and advanced courses in school. They refer to this phenomenon as maximizing the opportunities offered by the school curriculum. The question arises: can this factor serve as an indicator of a student's future success in higher education? Research in this area shows that in-depth study of complex subjects in school can contribute to the development of necessary skills and abilities that subsequently play a significant role in a successful academic career. Therefore, analyzing this aspect of the educational process is significant for predicting student success in higher education.

Researchers analyzed students' academic performance both in school and at university to identify the connection between these levels of education. They assessed how academic performance in school influences subsequent academic success in higher education. This analysis allows us to better understand the factors that contribute to academic success and how early achievement influences later academic success.

  • School data included the student's GPA over the past three years (high school GPA), ACT score, and whether they took the most challenging advanced courses in math, science, and English at school.
  • At the university, we took into account the student's GPA in their first year, whether they dropped out after the first year, and whether they subsequently completed their studies.

To account for the individual characteristics of each applicant, the school median, which is the average GPA of all high school students in a given educational institution, was subtracted from the absolute value of an indicator, for example, the GPA in high school. The resulting value was then divided by the standard deviation. Thus, the contextual GPA allows us to determine how close to or above the school average an applicant is. This approach provides a more accurate assessment of academic performance and takes into account the unique learning conditions at each school.

Sophisticated mathematical models have been developed to determine the relationships between students' contextual data and their success in college. These formulas take into account numerous factors, including sociodemographic characteristics, allowing for more accurate predictions of students' academic performance and subsequent career outcomes. This approach helps educational institutions better understand which aspects of preparation influence graduate success.

What the researchers found

The study confirmed the relationship between three contextual school indicators and student success in college. These data can serve as an effective tool for assessing applicants' prospects. Of all the indicators, contextual GPA in high school turned out to be the most reliable, making it the primary benchmark for admissions committees when evaluating candidates. Thus, focusing on this metric can significantly improve the accuracy of predicting student success in higher education.

Research shows that students with high high school GPAs are significantly more likely to succeed in their first year of college. These students not only achieve high results early in their education, but also have a higher chance of surviving their first year of study and successfully completing their undergraduate degree. High academic achievement in high school predicts continued success in higher education, underscoring the importance of a high-quality education early on.

Research shows that ACT scores are associated with student success in their first year, but this association is weaker than that of high school GPA. There is also a correlation between ACT scores and the likelihood of completing an undergraduate degree, but it is even weaker. The study's authors point out that some US universities ignore ACT scores, raising debate about the appropriateness of this approach. The study's findings suggest that the ACT score can be discounted, with high school GPA serving as a more reliable indicator of academic performance. Contextual data on advanced courses taken by applicants in high school proved to be the least reliable predictor of both first-year grades and the likelihood of dropping out. Therefore, admissions committees should not rely on these metrics when making admissions decisions. Questions about how to rank university applicants based on their individual characteristics are becoming increasingly pressing. How can we effectively collect and process large amounts of relevant data? Will the calculation formula prove too complex for practical application? These aspects are indeed important, but they can be worked out. The focus should be on assessing students within their context, which will create a fairer and more accurate selection system. Learn more about the world of education by subscribing to our Telegram channel. Here you'll find current news, helpful tips, and interesting materials to help you stay up-to-date on developments in the education sector. Join us and expand your knowledge!

Rework your text, maintaining the main topic and avoiding unnecessary details. Optimize the text for SEO and add necessary information. Avoid using emojis or unnecessary symbols, and avoid structuring it into bullet points. Focus on creating clear and understandable content.

Read also:

  • What's wrong with the modern university admissions system? 5 High-Tension Zones
  • University Admission Rules in 2024: The Ministry of Education and Science Changes the Procedure Again
  • 7 Facts About the 2023 University Admissions Campaign
  • Interesting Figures About University Admissions: Why Humanities Students Pay for Admission

Educational Program Methodologist

You will go through the full cycle of creating an educational product from scratch. Learn to design curricula for online and offline courses. You will become a universal specialist - you can launch your own project or get a job as a methodologist in a large company.

Find out more