Contents:

Learn: The Profession of Methodologist from Scratch to PRO
Learn More
Senior researcher at the Laboratory of Individualization and Continuous Education, associate professor at the Directorate of Educational Programs at Moscow City Pedagogical University (MCPU) and co-coordinator of the International Laboratory of Interactive Questioning. I am one of the authors of the book "Interactive Questioning: How the Ability to Ask Your Own Questions Helps You Develop." My work focuses on developing educational practices and implementing interactive teaching methods, which promotes deeper understanding of educational material and fosters critical thinking in students.
In 2021/2022, I was awarded a scholarship in the Vladimir Potanin Charitable Foundation's grant competition for master's degree teachers, with the "Scaling the Methodology of Interactive Questioning" program in the "New Teaching Methods" category. This experience has allowed me to implement modern approaches to teaching and improve the effectiveness of the educational process, which is especially important for training qualified specialists in a rapidly changing world.
In this interview, you will learn about:
- why people are afraid to ask questions during their studies and how to motivate them to do so;
- how students at one university were specifically taught to ask questions and what came of it;
- what is interactive questioning and how its simple techniques work;
- can a new interdisciplinary field emerge — questionology;
- how to improve problem-based or project-based learning using interactive questioning techniques.
The inability to ask questions as a problem in education
Why do students, whether schoolchildren or adults, often avoid asking questions about what they are studying? This situation is common during webinars: the presenter encourages participants to ask questions, but the only response is silence. There can be various reasons for this behavior. Firstly, many people are afraid of appearing incompetent or stupid in the eyes of others. Secondly, some simply don't know how to formulate their question correctly. It's also worth considering that people may have low self-confidence, which prevents them from openly expressing their thoughts. Finally, some participants may feel that their questions won't be of interest to others, which also leads to silence. To overcome these barriers, it's important to create an atmosphere of trust and support where everyone can freely express their doubts and interests. One of the key problems in education is that students often ignore unclear points in the course material. The lecturer presents information, and at some point, ambiguity arises. However, to ask a question, you first need to clearly identify what exactly is causing the difficulty. This process can be quite complex. Furthermore, social stereotypes influence the formulation of questions. For example, there's a belief that top students always know the answers to any teacher's questions, which can discourage other students from being proactive and asking questions. By asking a question, you demonstrate interest and a desire for knowledge. This isn't a sign of stupidity or academic failure, but rather a step toward understanding and self-improvement. Questions help deepen knowledge and develop critical thinking. Don't be afraid to ask, because every question is an opportunity to learn something new and discover new horizons. Yes, this is a basic attitude. A reluctance to ask questions may be due to a psychological aspect. People often experience fear or insecurity, which prevents them from openly expressing their thoughts and interests. This may be due to a fear of judgment, misunderstanding, or low self-esteem. Understanding these factors can help overcome internal barriers and learn to ask questions, which contributes to the development of personal and professional relationships. The social environment plays an important role in our learning and development. When we find ourselves in an environment where questioning is encouraged, we are inspired to explore and understand the world more deeply. It is in these environments that we become actively interested in our surroundings and develop our skills and knowledge. In educational settings, independent student questions are often suppressed because they are perceived as a waste of class time and a distraction from the teacher's focus on the curriculum. This leads to decreased student engagement and limits opportunities for deep understanding. It is important to create an educational environment where questions and discussions become an integral part of the learning process, fostering critical thinking and student independence. Teachers often ignore questions that begin with the word "why" because they can distract from the material being studied. For example, questions like "Why do we study this in history?" or "Why do humanities students need mathematics?" can slow down the learning process. However, it is important to understand that such questions can contribute to a deeper understanding of the subject and increase student interest. When approached correctly, these questions can stimulate discussion and in-depth analysis, which ultimately enriches the educational process.
Some children ask such questions to distract the teacher and discuss something unrelated to the lesson. This may be a way to attract attention or to demonstrate their initiative in communication.
Of course, such situations exist. However, there are also serious people who genuinely need to discuss certain issues, but they cannot do so in a general environment.
I asked two students from a respected Moscow school to record the number of questions they asked in class over the course of a week. In the end, one asked only one question, and the other asked two. This experiment emphasizes the importance of active student participation in the learning process and shows how students can sometimes be shy about asking questions, even in an environment favorable for learning.
In mainstream schools, there is often no space for inquisitive children who are eager to learn and ask questions. A restructuring of the teacher's work and the educational process itself is necessary. This is possible in institutions where the administration recognizes the importance of this approach, and where teachers have mastered effective methods and received positive feedback from students. Creating an open and supportive learning environment promotes the development of critical thinking and initiative in students. Learning and education are truly built on asking questions. This is a key process that contributes to deepening understanding and developing critical thinking. Questions encourage people to analyze information, seek answers, and expand their knowledge. Furthermore, by asking questions, students learn to formulate their thoughts and express their ideas, which is an important part of the educational process. Thus, active interaction through questions becomes the basis for effective learning and contributes to a deeper understanding of the topics being studied. Learning is not always effective. When the learning process is built on an authoritarian approach, it often suppresses student activity and limits their questions. Only superficial questions are resolved, such as "when is the assignment due?" or "how many spaces should I indent from the new line?" However, deeper questions about the essence of phenomena, their meaning, and alternative interpretations remain outside the scope of discussion. This limits critical thinking and hinders the development of students' ability to independently analyze and comprehend information.

If a person has not been taught If asking the right questions about the essence of things is something we learn as children, the question arises: is it possible to develop this ability in adulthood? Adults lacking critical thinking skills may struggle to formulate insightful questions. However, with the right approach and training, this important skill can be developed. Reflection, reading, and discussion can help develop the habit of asking meaningful questions, which in turn leads to a deeper understanding of the world around us. Learning how to ask questions becomes a key tool for personal and professional growth. Learning to ask questions can be done at any age, and the process is enjoyable, revealing new facets of one's personality. In our tutoring master's program, where I teach a course called "Questioning as a Culture of Tutoring Activity," there was a student who held the position of deputy director of a school. She was thirty-eight years old and had considerable experience. In her essay, she noted that during her studies, she asked more questions than in her entire life. She admitted, "If I'd known from childhood to ask questions, my life might have turned out differently." These words highlight the importance of developing critical thinking and active learning skills, which can be acquired through education and self-improvement.
For tutors, the ability to ask questions is an important professional tool, similar to the ability of psychotherapists. Effective student teaching requires developing questioning skills that deepen understanding of the material and stimulate critical thinking. For example, when teaching humanities students, a tutor might use the Socratic questioning method, asking provocative questions that encourage students to analyze and justify their opinions. This not only promotes deeper learning but also develops independent thinking skills in students, which is especially important in the modern educational process.
At one university, in the undergraduate program for future entrepreneurs and managers, we spent a semester organizing the learning process. Our main goal was to solve the problem I mentioned earlier: students often overlook unclear points in the learning process. We aimed to teach students to ask questions about unfamiliar topics and work with them effectively. This not only promotes better comprehension of the material but also develops critical thinking, an essential skill for future leaders and managers.
It's surprising that a special course was created for this purpose.
During the class, we quickly identified the students' goals for the course. Each selected the subject they considered the most challenging, and they all unanimously chose economics. The students then began generating questions related to this subject. As a result of the discussion, it became clear that the group of approximately 50 people was divided into two unequal parts: one group asked more complex and in-depth questions, while the other remained at a superficial level. This split in the perception of economics as a subject highlights the need for an individualized approach to learning and additional resources for students experiencing difficulties.
Most students asked questions focused on how to quickly pass the course. The primary emphasis was on passing, not on a deep understanding of the material. Only a small group of students had questions about the practical application of knowledge acquired in this subject.
Students who follow the first learning strategy are likely to forget the economics material after taking the exam. Meanwhile, the second group studies consciously, actively connecting the acquired knowledge to their future professional activities. These students demonstrate a deeper understanding of the subject matter and are better prepared for the real-world challenges of their careers.

Those who chose the first strategy, striving to quickly and Passing economics easily, the practice of asking questions helped me understand important aspects. Understanding the significance of questions helps me understand the material more deeply and improve my learning. It's important not only to strive for a quick pass, but also to approach economics consciously, which can lead to better understanding of the subject and higher results. Our main goal is to create a space where a variety of questions arise and where reflection occurs. Why are the questions so varied? Some openly admit: "I don't know why I study; my parents just sent me here." However, if such a person observes others who approach learning with a different attitude, they begin to reflect. You can continue to live by old habits, or you can change your mindset to be more conscious and purposeful. This awareness can spark change and development, which in turn fosters a deeper understanding of the learning process and its significance in life.
By discussing questions, students not only better understand their difficulties with the subject but also identify areas they need to clarify before the next test. They also understand which topics require more in-depth study before the exam and who they can turn to for help with any questions that arise. This contributes to better learning and improved academic performance.
The ability to ask questions is an important skill that needs to be developed in educational institutions. It may be worth including this skill in the Federal State Educational Standards (FSES) as a separate meta-subject outcome. This will allow this skill to be given due attention and ensure its systematic development in the school and university curriculum. Introducing such an element into the educational process can significantly enhance students' critical thinking and analytical skills, which are key factors for future professional success.
God forbid that this happens.
Why is this so important?
Federal State Educational Standards (FSES) significantly influence the educational process, sometimes turning it into a formal structure. As a developer of interactive questioning, I strive to avoid introducing such standards into educational communication. Our strategy is to find and train educational institution administrators—principals and vice-rectors—as well as interested teachers. If a teacher is not interested in questions themselves, they will not be able to inspire their students to actively question and explore. We focus on creating an environment where questioning becomes the norm, not the exception, which fosters deeper understanding and develops critical thinking in students.
The question of teachers' and school principals' interest in modern educational methods and innovations remains relevant. It is often observed that many educators are eager to implement new approaches to teaching, but the level of interest varies. It is important to note that interest primarily depends on the individual values and professional aspirations of each teacher or educational institution leader. Some actively seek opportunities for professional growth and development and are willing to experiment with new methods, while others may remain skeptical or see no need for change. This underscores the importance of creating a supportive environment that promotes the exchange of experiences and the introduction of innovations into the educational process.
Private schools show greater interest in individualized learning compared to public institutions. This is due to the desire to move away from a mass approach to education and implement active learning techniques. However, there are also positive examples of the implementation of such methods in public schools. I recently trained the staff of one of the large municipal schools in Moscow, which confirms that interest in individualized learning is present in state institutions as well.

When you use the words "we" and "ours," who do you mean? Who is working with you to develop a culture of questioning?
I'm talking about an informal online community interested in this topic that began to form in 2016. Initially, it was created on the now-banned Facebook social network, and we are currently actively developing a VKontakte group and a Telegram channel. Our community is international in nature, as members live in different countries. We organize free educational events and exchange experiences at two international conferences held by the Moscow State University of Psychology and Education (MSPU), where I work. One conference is dedicated to tutoring, and the other to continuing education. We also conduct lectures and webinars at the Pervoe Sentyabrya publishing house and the Yurait platform. Join us to stay informed about current trends and share knowledge in education and tutoring.
Our community is distinguished by its diverse membership. It includes representatives from the education sector, working in schools, and business professionals. Questioning techniques are widely used in modern business, for example, during planning meetings and facilitation sessions. Each participant can contribute their unique experience and knowledge. We are particularly interested in attracting experienced mathematics and physics methodologists who can use our developments to develop specialized techniques for these subjects. This will help enrich our community and expand opportunities for sharing experiences.
Questioning techniques are applicable not only to developing critical thinking and in the humanities but are also effectively used in teaching the exact and natural sciences. These methods help deepen understanding of the material, develop analytical skills, and develop the ability to solve complex problems. Thus, the use of questioning techniques in educational processes can significantly improve the quality of learning in various fields.
An experiment conducted in 2008 in Israel demonstrated the effectiveness of this learning approach using a sample of high school students studying chemistry. Students with similar knowledge levels were divided into two groups and given chemistry assignments they had previously studied in school. The results showed that both groups completed the tasks at approximately the same level. This study highlights the importance of group learning and its impact on learning, and also opens up new possibilities for improving educational methods in the natural sciences.
One of the groups was asked to ask questions before starting to work on a problem. These questions include: What is the given statement? What is the unknown? What are the main conditions of the problem? Therefore, before starting to solve, it is important to analyze the problem using these key questions. This contributes to a deeper understanding of the problem and increases the chances of a successful solution.
After this, both groups were given new problems that they had not encountered before, but were not provided with explanations for their solutions. As a result, the group trained in formulating questions completed these tasks significantly better. This clearly demonstrates the importance of questioning skills in the learning and problem-solving process.
What is interactive questioning and who invented it?
You are not just doing general questions, but specialized techniques of interactive questioning. This is a method that allows for effective interaction with an audience, stimulating active participation and a deep understanding of the topics under discussion. Interactive questioning techniques help create a dialogue in which participants not only answer questions but also ask them, making the learning and communication process more productive. The questions a person asks themselves can be divided into prepersonal and personal. Prepersonal questions include: "Why is this happening to me?", "What's wrong with me?", "Why do others always win?", and "What is my goal?" These questions reflect self-pity, judgment, envy of others, and dependence on authority figures. Immanuel Kant, in his work "Answer to the Question: What is Enlightenment," described this state as "immaturity." Understanding these questions and their causes can help a person recognize their own limitations and strive for personal growth. Reflecting on your inner state and seeking answers to these questions are important steps towards self-awareness and development.
Personal questions play a key role in the process of self-knowledge and understanding your values. They help us define who we are, how we want to live, and which path we will choose. By asking ourselves questions such as "What am I like?" or "What can I do?", a person begins to recognize their capabilities and limitations. Accepting these questions changes the perception of life and allows us to avoid a state of weak-willed flesh carried by the flow of circumstances. It is important to understand that personal and prepersonal questions require different approaches: the former focuses on the inner world and individual values, and the latter on external factors and public opinion. By reflecting on personal questions, we open new horizons for personal growth and development.
There are two typologies of questioning: asymmetrical and symmetrical. In a hierarchical society, the types of questions that can be asked depend on the social and career status of the questioner. For example, a subordinate can ask a superior or teacher how to complete a task, but is not allowed to ask why. This demonstrates asymmetrical questioning opportunities. In contrast, in a heterogeneous society, the opportunities to ask questions are equal for all participants, making them symmetrical. Understanding these typologies is therefore important for analyzing social interactions and communication in various structures. Interactive questioning facilitates the transition from impersonal communication to personal interaction, as well as from asymmetrical to symmetrical relationships. We are developing effective techniques for implementing these approaches.

This technique is a way for a person to achieve something through asking questions. maturity and develop a more conscious approach to life.
Interactive questioning provides an opportunity to become a co-author of your life. The emergence of personal questions indicates the achievement of "coming of age" in self-understanding, according to Kant's philosophy. This process of self-reflection and active search for answers helps develop personality and deepen the awareness of one's goals and values.
Philosophy arises from questions. What philosophical schools and thinkers do your ideas draw on? Perhaps you draw inspiration from the methods of Socrates with his famous dialectical method?
In webinars dedicated to questioning, I present a slide demonstrating the historical continuity of approaches to this process. Many names are represented on this map, and it is impossible to single out one specific person who fully developed the concept of questioning. This area of knowledge has been explored and developed by many people over time.

As As a starting point for our discussion, we consider the ideas of Socrates, Plato, and Aristotle. Aristotle argued that true knowledge is available only to those who ask questions. This means that knowledge cannot simply be transferred from one person to another. It emerges through interaction between student and teacher. This process requires the active participation of both parties, making learning dynamic and mutually beneficial. Thus, learning is not only a transfer of information but also a collaborative exploration and discovery of new horizons.
Interactive questioning is the skill of formulating effective questions. This process involves asking questions that promote a deep understanding of the topic and the active involvement of participants. The right questions help uncover the essence of the problem, stimulate discussion, and facilitate the exchange of opinions. Interactive questioning is an important tool in educational and communication processes, as it allows not only to obtain information but also to develop critical thinking.
The questioning method of thinking is a key approach to intellectual development. For example, Israeli colleagues emphasize that questioning is a higher intellectual function. This approach promotes a deeper understanding and analysis of information, enabling the identification of hidden aspects and the development of original solutions. Using questioning in education and professional work stimulates critical thinking and creativity, which is especially important in today's world, where information is constantly evolving and becoming more complex.
Approaches to questioning in educational institutions can vary significantly across countries. However, in all cases, this phenomenon is associated with the development of thinking and the formation of three types of questions: questions about oneself, questions about others, and questions about the content. In the context of the educational process, special attention is paid to questions related to the content of the course. These questions help students more deeply comprehend the material, develop critical thinking, and build lasting knowledge. Effective questioning promotes active engagement in the learning process and allows for a better understanding of the topic being studied.
Interactive questioning is a method that my colleagues and co-authors of the book of the same name and I actively use in our practice. Its essence lies in creating a dialogue between participants, which not only deepens understanding of the topics under discussion but also stimulates critical thinking. This approach promotes the development of ideas and allows each participant to contribute to the overall discussion. Unlike traditional methods, interactive questioning emphasizes active listening and questioning, which helps uncover hidden aspects of a topic. By using this method, we strive to create a space for an open exchange of opinions, which ultimately enriches our research and makes it more relevant. Our approach has three key features. The first is that we artificially slow down the process of question generation by participants. This helps avoid the reflexive urge to quickly answer without thinking through the topic. The second feature is that each participant formulates questions based on their own understanding of the topic or problem under discussion. We highly value the ability to generate your own questions and differ from other authors who offer pre-prepared lists of questions. The third feature is that we train participants to share their questions with others and discuss them, which significantly improves the quality of dialogue and deepens understanding of the topic.
Interactive questioning arose from the need to create a more dynamic and engaging communication process. It became a response to users' needs for real-time information acquisition and interaction with content. This approach combines elements of traditional surveys and modern technologies, allowing participants to actively participate in discussions. Interactive questioning attracts attention and promotes a deeper understanding of the topic, making it a valuable tool in education, marketing, and other fields.
Since 2014, I have been working with Vera Leonidovna Danilova and a group of like-minded people on the development of promising thinking technologies within the framework of strategic games organized by Petr Shchedrovitsky. We explored various approaches, drawing on our personal experiences and cultural traditions. Our work led us to the conclusion that a thinking technology focused on questioning is necessary.
In our research, we identified three main approaches to questioning in this area. The most common is that questions are generated externally—by someone else. For example, in an interview, you might ask me questions. The Socratic method, incidentally, also relies on questions posed by someone else, not the subject themselves. This typically occurs in interactions with authority figures, such as teachers, bosses, doctors, or interviewers who have the authority to ask questions.
The second, less common approach involves individuals asking themselves questions. These questions are typically aimed at generating meaning and seeking information. This approach helps them gain a deeper understanding of their thoughts and goals and fosters a more conscious perception of the world around them. Independent reflection and exploratory questions can be a powerful tool for personal growth and the development of critical thinking.
The third type of questioning involves questions that arise and are discussed within organized communication. This is a process in which a group of people collaborate on a specific topic or problem. We call this type of questioning interactive questioning, and it is the focus of our development and improvement efforts. Interactive questioning promotes deep analysis and exchange of opinions, making it an effective tool for solving complex problems.
The third type of group communication questioning differs from the first type, which involves external questions, in its internal focus. While external questions often concern information coming from external sources or touch on opinions and expectations, the third type of question focuses on interactions within the group. These questions are aimed at deepening understanding, clarifying participants' positions, and discussing internal processes. Thus, the third type of question promotes deeper analysis and discussion within the group, which helps to increase the effectiveness of group communication and improve the results of teamwork. External questions may not influence a person, not prompting them to reflect or discover. They may be purely informational. However, such questions can stimulate thinking, provided that a person is in an intellectual or philosophical school, or in a scientific research environment. In such conditions, specific questions arise that facilitate new insights. Certain elite conditions are necessary for this, and a person must be lucky to find themselves in such an environment. To find your Socrates, you need to delve into philosophical reflection and examine your own values. It is important to ask yourself key questions about the meaning of life, truth, and moral principles. Understanding philosophical concepts will help you form your own opinion and find inspiration in the teachings of great thinkers. By combining personal experience and philosophical ideas, you can come closer to understanding your true goals and aspirations. Questions of the third type represent a form of shared reflection, in which participants are on equal terms when seeking both questions and answers. Within this category of questions, technology is emphasized in group communication. This implies the development of universal methods that can be used, for example, by any teacher in a classroom with students. Teaching these techniques should be simple and take no more than an hour. Since 2016, we have developed over 30 different methods that can be used not only in education. Depending on the specific practical task, different techniques can be applied, making them universal and adaptable to various conditions. These techniques are widely used in marketing to increase the effectiveness of advertising campaigns and improve customer interactions. In education, these methods help develop learning materials and increase student engagement. In healthcare, the techniques are used to improve patient care and optimize processes. They can also be found in software development, where they facilitate more effective project management and improve communication between teams. These techniques are universal and can be adapted to the specific needs of each sector, making them a valuable tool in today's environment. We identify three key areas. The first is life management. This is a topic I've already mentioned: by asking mature questions, a person can become a co-author of their life, not just a passive participant. The second area includes intellectual games that develop thinking and creativity. The third, most extensive area, concerns practical problem solving. This area covers such aspects as question-based learning, effective communication, facilitation and negotiation, leadership and team building, as well as research and strategy design. These areas help develop the skills necessary for the successful implementation of projects and goal achievement.
Who else is developing questioning techniques?
When developing my interactive questioning techniques, I relied on existing work in this field. Scientific research and practical methods created by other specialists served as the basis for shaping my approaches. There are many researchers and practitioners around the world who are developing and studying interactive questioning methods. These practices are applied in various fields, including education, psychology, and business. Interactive questioning is an important tool for increasing engagement and improving communication, and its study continues to evolve.
There are several organizations with which we actively collaborate. We are particularly attracted to the approach of the HAN University of Applied Sciences in the Netherlands. We adapted their methodology, which combines the use of digital mind maps and the brainstorming method with questions. This allows for the effective organization of information and the generation of ideas, significantly improving learning and innovative thinking.
The teacher begins creating a mind map by writing the main topic in the center. On one side of the map, key questions are highlighted in blue, which students answer. On the opposite side, question words are written in orange. Students must formulate questions using these words and find answers to them. This approach allows for a deeper exploration of the topic and makes the learning process engaging and intellectually rich.

The Right Question Institute operates in the United States. Its main goal is to teach people how to formulate their own questions, enabling them to actively participate in decision-making processes, including political ones and everyday ones, such as medical ones. For example, patients can learn to ask the right questions of their doctors, which will help them make informed decisions about their treatment. The Institute is also active in the field of education and has developed a strategy based on question formulation. We use some of their methods. Furthermore, since 2019, Harvard University has offered an online course on the use of question formulation techniques, developed by specialists from this institute.
The University of Aveiro in Portugal is conducting research on the use of student questions as alternative assessment methods. This approach opens new possibilities for assessing student knowledge and engagement. Other institutions are also experimenting with similar methods, indicating a growing interest in innovative forms of assessment in the educational process.
Is there an international community of specialists researching and developing question-based techniques? Can this field be considered a professional field? Questionology, as a field of knowledge, studies the methods and approaches that enable effective questioning to obtain information, develop critical thinking, and improve communication. In recent years, there has been a growing interest in this field, which has contributed to the formation of professional communities and organizations uniting experts in this field. Such communities can exchange experiences, conduct research, and develop methodologies, which, in turn, contributes to the popularization of questioning techniques in various fields, including education, business, and psychology.
A new scientific community is currently forming, bringing together various fields and interests. Several years ago, one of the initiators in the United States proposed the creation and development of an interdisciplinary field called questionology. This is a clear example of how new ideas and concepts are beginning to develop and take shape. In the future, we may see the emergence of educational institutions specializing in the art of questioning, as well as international conferences dedicated to this pressing topic. Questionology is becoming an important aspect of the scientific and educational process, opening up new horizons for study and knowledge exchange.
The Methodologist profession from scratch to PRO
You will improve your skills in developing curricula for online and offline courses. Master modern teaching practices, structure your experience, and become a more sought-after specialist.
Find out more
