Contents:

Course with employment: "Profession Methodologist from scratch to PRO"
Learn moreAn e-textbook, an interactive longread, a series of short posts, or a dialogue with a chatbot are significantly different from a traditional printed book. However, all of these formats are text, just like a substantial tome found in a library. It's important to understand which of these formats is most effective for educational purposes. Let's consider the advantages and disadvantages of each of them in order to determine the optimal approach to learning in the modern world.
In this article, you will find information about…
- what are the fundamental differences between reading electronic texts and paper ones;
- when reading which texts, people cope better with comprehension tasks;
- what conditions influence the reading result;
- is it true that young people prefer electronic texts;
- how to make electronic reading more thoughtful.
How the screen is not like paper
Scientists have been studying the differences in the perception of electronic and printed texts since the advent of computers in our lives. Important findings on this topic were summarized by researchers from the A.S. Pushkin State Institute of the Russian Language in a recent review of scientific papers. Linguists analyzed 119 studies and identified three key characteristics of e-text comprehension. First, the reading speed of electronic materials is higher, due to users' habit of quickly obtaining information. Second, users are more often distracted by external factors when reading on a screen, which can negatively impact comprehension. Third, e-texts are generally perceived less seriously, reflecting their attitude as a less formal source of information. These findings highlight the importance of understanding the peculiarities of text comprehension in various formats, which can influence their effectiveness in educational and professional settings. Non-linearity. Hyperlinks, unlike footnotes in a printed book, do more than simply point to the source of information. The reader of an e-text decides each time whether to follow the link or stay on the page, and constructs their own path through the material. Interactivity. The most a reader can do with a printed text is underline a few lines, bookmark a page, or write a note in the margins. Electronic text can be copied or highlighted, searched within a page or in a search engine, read aloud, and open-ended comments can be left and discussions with the author and other readers can be initiated.
Text features can both enhance comprehension and distract readers. A total of 119 studies failed to find a single, universal answer to this question. Each element of text design and structure is evaluated differently depending on the context and audience. Therefore, it is important to consider how these features affect information comprehension and retention.
- Hyperlinks typically increase reading load and interfere with comprehension and retention of material. But there is no such effect for texts from encyclopedias.
- Interactivity has a positive effect on text comprehension and learning, especially for primary school-aged children.
- The data regarding combining different formats on a single page is contradictory. In most cases, the principle of modality applies. We perceive graphics, video, and text visually, that is, they have the same modality. Therefore, reading complex material simultaneously from video and text is difficult: the visual channel of perception is overloaded. However, if complex graphics are accompanied by audio, then two different channels are used, and neither is overloaded. However, this principle does not work when learning a foreign language - although it is useful to watch a video and read subtitles at the same time.
Digital formats have an interesting characteristic: they practically do not use the sense of touch. Unlike printed publications, which are physical objects and are perceived not only visually, digital materials are devoid of tactile sensations. This change in information perception affects the experience of reading and interacting with content, making it more homogeneous and limited.
American linguist Naomi Baron emphasizes that we often use location in a book, whether it's "somewhere at the beginning" or "in the middle," as a marker for remembering information. This approach helps readers navigate the text and process the material more effectively. Using spatial cues in reading promotes better assimilation and recall of information.
Electronic texts lack spatial markers, which is especially noticeable when scrolling, as opposed to turning pages. This leads to an unstable text, and mental notes lose their anchor. In printed texts, such markers play an important role, ensuring ease of navigation and information comprehension. Proper use of spatial markers in printed materials promotes better text comprehension and increases readability.
Research shows that readers using paper books are better able to navigate the chronology of stories than those using e-readers. This is likely due to the physical perception of a book influencing plot comprehension. The feeling of the beginning and end of a work in the hands of the reader creates a unique experience that promotes better memorization.

Which reading is more effective for
Reading on a screen is different from reading a printed book, even if the content is identical. This has serious implications for the learning process. Research shows that information comprehension and retention can be less effective when reading on a screen. Many students have difficulty concentrating and remembering information in digital format. Printed textbooks make it easier to take notes, highlight important points, and maintain attention.
Can electronic versions completely replace printed textbooks? This question remains open. Electronic textbooks are convenient and accessible, but their use requires adaptation of teaching methods. It is important to consider the individual preferences of students and choose the optimal format for their educational process. Thus, a combination of print and electronic textbooks may be the most effective solution for today's students.
Research on which format is better for information comprehension and retention has been conducted for several generations. In 1992, the first review was published, which summarized the results of hundreds of scientific papers on this topic. It focused on the difficulties of reading on screens, which were caused by the limitations of the technology of the time. Since then, the question of text perception has remained relevant, given the rapid development of digital devices and platforms.
A 2018 review by Pablo Delgado and colleagues from the University of Valencia and the Technion - Israel Institute of Technology has become the primary source of data on this topic. The work summarized the results of 54 studies conducted between 2000 and 2017. This review provides valuable insights and analysis that can be useful for both researchers and practitioners in the relevant field.
The study involved 171,000 people, primarily students and schoolchildren. The analysis assessed which text format is better perceived by readers: print or its electronic counterpart. It is important to note that the review did not include studies in which the electronic text contained significant differences from the print version, such as hyperlinks or web navigation elements. This approach allows us to focus on comparing pure text formats, which contributes to a more accurate understanding of reading preferences.
The review authors used a meta-analysis method, which allowed them to recalculate the results based on published data and combine them into a single format. In most cases, they found that reading printed text is more effective than other formats.
Across 56 experiments, they found that readers using paper media demonstrated better results in text comprehension tasks. Only in 18 cases were situations observed where readers of electronic texts gave more accurate answers. However, in a number of cases, the differences in results between the reading groups were insignificant.
Two more meta-analyses were soon published, which came to similar conclusions. These studies confirm the previous results and highlight the importance of the topic under consideration.
- A 2018 review by researchers from the State University of New York at Buffalo included 17 studies, mostly published after 2010. Some of them (with a total of approximately 4,800 participants) assessed text comprehension after reading. The review showed that reading printed text is more effective.
- In 2019, Virginia Clinton, a researcher at the University of North Dakota (USA), reviewed studies covering a shorter period of time than her Spanish and Israeli colleagues: from 2008 to 2018. In total, she analyzed 29 publications that described the results of 33 experiments with approximately 2,800 participants, and also found a slight advantage in comprehension of printed text compared to electronic text.
What conditions affect reading results
Research shows that, on average, people understand and remember information presented in print better. However, generalizing "on average" can be misleading. The three reviews presented both studies confirming the advantage of paper and those indicating the higher effectiveness of digital devices. Why do such contradictions arise? Maria Lebedeva, a leading researcher at the Laboratory of Cognitive and Linguistic Studies at the Pushkin Institute, answers this question.
Differences in results can be due to many factors, including the diversity of samples, the devices used in the experiments, reading conditions, as well as methods for assessing the quality of reading comprehension, and other aspects. These elements can significantly influence the final results and their interpretation.
Pablo Delgado and colleagues identified a number of factors that negatively impact the effectiveness of on-screen reading. These conditions include insufficient text contrast, complex fonts, and pages that are overloaded with visual elements. These aspects can make it difficult to perceive information and reduce a reader’s concentration. Optimizing reading conditions, such as using clear fonts and improving contrast, can significantly improve the quality of on-screen text perception.
- limited reading time;
- informational nature of the text (as opposed to pure storytelling);
- using a computer rather than a tablet, smartphone, or e-reader;
- scrolling text instead of turning pages.
Differences in results can be due to several factors, including the use of different samples, different devices used in the experiments, reading conditions, and the methods used to assess reading comprehension. These aspects play a key role in the interpretation of the obtained data and can significantly influence the conclusions drawn from them. Taking all these factors into account is necessary for a more accurate analysis of the results and to increase their reliability.
What about age and screen reading
Spanish and Israeli researchers came to an unexpected conclusion: from 2000 to 2017, the benefits of the print reading format became more pronounced. Research shows that new generations who grew up in the era of technology and gadgets, known as "digital natives", do not demonstrate a higher ability to perceive text from a screen compared to previous generations. This underscores the importance of the print format for the full perception of information.
Children's reading is an important component of a child's development. Research shows that regular reading helps improve vocabulary, develop imagination and critical thinking. Reading books helps foster a love of literature in children and also develops social skills and emotional intelligence. Parents and caregivers should actively encourage children to read by providing access to a variety of books and creating a comfortable environment for this activity. Thus, reading becomes not only a source of knowledge but also an engaging pastime for children.
According to a 2017 study conducted by researchers at the University of Maryland, children aged 5-6 demonstrate similar comprehension skills for both printed and digital text. For short texts, the format does not play a significant role in their comprehension. This finding highlights the importance of accessibility to both print and digital materials for children's early learning.

In a more recent and detailed study covering 30 papers with A study involving over 1,800 people, primarily children aged 4-5, confirmed previous findings. On average, the reading format did not significantly affect the effectiveness of text comprehension. In experiments using digital books containing interactive elements such as dictionaries, audio reading, and clickable images, a slight advantage of reading on-screen was recorded.
In some experiments, e-books showed a lower level of engagement compared to print editions. Nevertheless, learning new words through e-books proved to be more effective. However, at the moment, the advantages of digital formats cannot completely replace the importance of live communication and support from an adult. Reading aloud with a child from a printed book continues to be a more useful and developmental activity.
The same principles apply for teenagers as for adults. The results of studies conducted among schoolchildren and students show similar conclusions. This confirms that approaches to learning and skill development remain universal across different age groups.
In 2020, a team of researchers from the Pushkin Institute conducted an online survey among Russian students in grades 5–11 to study their reading behavior. Participants, 568 adolescents with an average age of 14 from 54 Russian regions, primarily girls, were asked to rate their reading skills both on screen and from paper media. The survey results unexpectedly coincided with data from scientific experiments, confirming the importance of studying the reading habits of young people in today's digital world.
Most adolescents report reading faster on screen, but they tire more quickly, lose interest, and are less focused. Furthermore, they are less likely to remember what they read compared to reading printed books. A 2017 study, which involved over 2,800 German schoolchildren in grades 1–6, confirms these findings. Children reading electronic texts demonstrated high reading speed, but this resulted in a superficial perception of information and decreased accuracy in problem solving. These findings highlight the importance of printed books for deep comprehension and retention of reading material.
Paper books remain the preferred choice for students, as they facilitate more effective information comprehension. Despite the development of digital technologies, the majority of university students worldwide still choose printed educational materials. These findings were obtained as a result of the Academic Reading Format International Study (AFRIS). Printed books promote better concentration and retention of material, which is especially important in the educational process.
From 2014 to 2017, more than 21,000 students from 33 countries, including Russia, participated in an international online survey. This survey provided valuable information about the opinions and preferences of young people on various issues affecting education and career aspirations. The survey results highlight global trends in learning and professional development, while also revealing differences between regions.
- 71% responded that they prefer to learn from printed course materials;
- 20.3% did not express a strong preference;
- Only 8.7% reported that they choose the electronic format.
While the share of preferences between print and electronic formats varies across countries, the trend toward using print publications remains global. It is particularly noticeable that younger students prefer printed materials, while graduate and postgraduate students more often choose electronic formats. Interestingly, the gender of respondents did not influence the choice of format.
Survey participants were able to explain their choices in the comments. As a result, we received a number of popular responses that reflect the opinions and preferences of respondents.
Proponents of the print format argue that digital materials can negatively affect vision.

To date, research comparing the effectiveness of traditional and digital reading among middle-aged and older adults remains limited. Most often, such studies involve students studying at the same university as the researchers. According to available data, Pablo Delgado and his colleagues did not find significant differences in digital reading effectiveness between adults of different age groups. This highlights the need for further research to better understand the impact of reading format on information comprehension in different age groups.
Print text, including books, textbooks, or individual materials, is ineffective when simply transferred to a screen. This approach loses the benefits of the print format and does not take advantage of the opportunities offered by digital technology. It is important to adapt content for screen viewing to maximize the interactivity and accessibility offered by the digital format. Effective digital content should be structured, visually appealing, and easy to navigate, making it easier for users to digest and engage with information.

