Education

Self-employed or sole proprietor? We explain the differences and discuss civil-law contracts and the benefits of an employment contract

Self-employed or sole proprietor? We explain the differences and discuss civil-law contracts and the benefits of an employment contract

Try 4 top professions in design. Free ➞ In 5 days, you'll get acquainted with illustration, UX/UI, web, and graphic design. Add 4 compelling case studies to your portfolio and decide on your next career direction.

Learn more

When outsourcing, you'll inevitably encounter the terms "civil law contracts" and "individual entrepreneurship." Your client's accountant may strongly recommend registering as self-employed. But what do these terms actually mean? What are the disadvantages of a simple contract? Is individual entrepreneur status necessary, and what advantages does self-employment offer? In this article, we'll examine all the aspects and nuances associated with these issues in detail.

From a legal perspective, anyone performing work under a contract is considered an individual. Individuals may apply special tax regimes, which affect their tax payment procedures. Although the contracts remain the same, the tax system in this case is different, which is important to take into account when concluding agreements. A proper understanding of these nuances will help avoid legal problems and effectively manage tax liabilities.

Various contracts are concluded with individuals that regulate the legal relations between the parties. These agreements may include purchase and sale agreements, leases, loans, and other types of transactions. Proper execution of such contracts is important to protect the interests of both parties and prevent potential conflicts. When concluding an agreement with an individual, it is necessary to take into account all legal aspects, such as the consent of the parties, the subject of the agreement, the conditions for the fulfillment of obligations, and the consequences for their violation. A clear understanding of all terms will help avoid misunderstandings and ensure the reliability of the transaction.

  • employment contract;
  • civil law contract (CLC).

An individual can perform various actions and make decisions within the scope of their legal capacity. Such opportunities include: concluding transactions, participating in civil circulation, protecting their rights and legitimate interests, and filing a lawsuit. In addition, an individual has the right to open bank accounts, receive loans, participate in investments and carry out entrepreneurial activities. All these actions require compliance with the law and may have various legal consequences.

  • register as self-employed;
  • become an individual entrepreneur (IE).

In addition to this, we will consider the hidden nuances and pitfalls that may arise in the process.

  • shadow employment.

Employment contract

When working permanently in an office, most employees work under an employment contract. This contract is concluded with the employer upon employment in an agency or company. This type of employment relationship is regulated by the norms of the Labor Code of the Russian Federation, which ensures the protection of the rights of employees and employers. The employment contract defines the working conditions, obligations of the parties, as well as the guarantees and compensation provided by law. This allows you to establish clear rules for interaction within the employment relationship.

An employment contract specifies your position, responsibilities, salary, and working hours. According to the Labor Code, the employer is obligated to provide you with a workstation and the necessary equipment. This includes not only a desk, computer, and tablet, but also all the necessary software to complete your tasks. A properly executed employment contract is important for protecting your rights and ensuring comfortable working conditions.

The basic rules that both employees and employers must comply with are set out in the Labor Code of the Russian Federation. This document regulates labor relations, establishes the rights and responsibilities of both parties, and defines working conditions, occupational safety, and the procedure for resolving labor disputes. Compliance with the Labor Code ensures the protection of workers' rights and contributes to a safe and effective work environment.

According to the law, you acquire the status of an employee upon signing an employment contract or on the date specified in this document. In some cases, an employee's status is established from the moment they actually begin performing their job duties.

The Labor Code reliably protects employees' rights, and employment contracts are the most advantageous option. This provides you with the opportunity to receive annual paid leave, sick leave, and maternity leave with job security. According to labor law, employers are required to pay overtime, and, most importantly, you cannot be fired without good cause. Having an employment contract guarantees stability and protection of your rights as an employee.

Labor law protects the interests of both employees and employers. Liability can take various forms, such as fines, compensation, or termination of the employment contract. Dismissal can be unilateral, and in some cases, violations of labor laws can lead to criminal prosecution. Understanding and adhering to labor laws is essential to creating a safe and fair work environment.

Employers' responsibilities to their employees include a significant number of rights, which entails the need for regular contributions to health, social, and pension insurance funds. These contributions form the basis for social benefits such as pensions and various benefits. Regular contributions provide employees with financial support for the future, making them an important aspect of stability and security in the labor market.

Some companies understate official salaries in documents to reduce tax contributions. As a result, the difference is paid to employees "under the table." In some cases, employers avoid concluding employment contracts altogether. This practice is known as shadow employment, and we will examine its consequences in more detail below.

The guarantees of an employment contract largely define your obligations. A contract often binds you to a specific workplace, establishes fixed working hours, and requires vacation time to be agreed upon with management. While this approach provides stability, in creative professions it can create a feeling of limitation.

An employment contract is the optimal choice for those who value stability and confidence in the future. It ensures regular payments and protects the employee's rights in accordance with labor legislation. However, such stability can limit freedom and opportunities for flexible work arrangements.

Civil Law Contract

Cooperation under a civil law contract is the most accessible way to formalize the relationship between a freelancer and a client. In this process, the parties agree on the terms of the contract, including a description of the task, the cost of services, and the deadlines. After reaching a mutual understanding, the document is signed by both parties, which provides legal protection for each party to the transaction. This approach allows freelancers to clearly define their obligations and rights, while clients are guaranteed completion within the established deadlines.

This work format is ideal for people who value flexibility and freedom in their schedule. A civil law contract offers a variety of opportunities, allowing you to be independent of a specific workplace and fixed schedule. This opens the door to working from anywhere in the world, creating a comfortable environment for productivity and self-realization.

Civil law relations (CLR) differ from labor relations and are regulated by the Civil Code of the Russian Federation. While an employment contract focuses on the employee's performance, a civil contract focuses on obtaining a specific result from the contractor. This key difference determines the legal consequences and obligations of the parties. Civil contracts are used in various fields, including services, contracting, and copyright, allowing for a flexible approach to the organization of work and interactions between the parties.

When drawing up a civil law contract, it is important to clearly spell out all the terms related to the performance of the work. Key aspects include the type of license under which the completed work will be transferred, the payment scheme, as well as penalties for breach of contract and the procedure for resolving potential disputes. Clarity and completeness of these terms will help avoid misunderstandings and protect the interests of the parties.

Rework the text, but stay on-topic and don't add anything extra. Optimize the text for SEO and add additional information if necessary. Avoid using emoticons and extra characters, and don't create sections with numbers or symbols. Please provide clear text.

Read also:

Copyright and types of licenses in the contract are important aspects of intellectual property protection. Copyright provides protection for creative works, such as literary works, music, films, and software. It is important to understand that copyright arises automatically from the moment a work is created, but its full protection often requires a license agreement.

Licenses are divided into several types, including exclusive and non-exclusive. An exclusive license grants the licensee the right to use the work, excluding the author's right to use it. A non-exclusive license, in turn, allows the author to grant similar rights to several people simultaneously. It is also important to consider territorial restrictions and the duration of the license, which can significantly affect the commercial use of the work.

In addition, there are Creative Commons licenses that allow authors to set the terms of use of their work, including permission for adaptation and commercial use. Understanding copyright and the various types of licenses will help protect the interests of both authors and users of works, ensuring the legal and ethical use of intellectual property.

Agencies often provide a standard contract, developed by in-house lawyers, which primarily takes into account the interests of the client. It is important to carefully read the document. If any points do not suit you or you would like to make additions, do not hesitate to request amendments. For example, terms regarding penalties for failure to fulfill obligations or early termination of the contract may be spelled out not only for you but also for the other party. This will help create a more balanced cooperation.

Relations arising under a civil law contract (CLC) are not legally considered employment relationships, which excludes the application of the provisions of the Labor Code. This means that income received under a CLC is not subject to deductions to insurance funds, including pension funds. Employees acting under such a contract are not entitled to paid vacation or sick leave. It's important to note that terminating a contract without good cause is extremely difficult, which protects the interests of both parties. However, the same difficulty applies to termination by the contractor: abandoning a project and failing to deliver the completed work also cannot be done without consequences.

Payments under a civil law contract (CLC) are taxable, like any other income. Unless you are self-employed or have chosen the simplified tax system for individual entrepreneurs, the personal income tax rate (PIT) is 13%. For legal entities, this tax is withheld from your fee, so it is important to ensure that the contract amount includes the 13% tax. If the contract is concluded between individuals, the tax must be paid personally. Proper drafting and understanding of tax obligations will help avoid financial risks and ensure compliance with the law.

A civil law contract (CLC) is ideal for freelancers who work on an irregular basis. If the client is a company, the document processing process is quite simple, and the tax obligations are assumed by the client. However, it is worth considering that one of the main disadvantages of working under a civil-law contract is the high personal income tax rate (PIT), which is 13%. In this regard, many companies prefer the self-employed or individual entrepreneurs (IE), which makes this format less attractive for freelancers.

Self-employed

Self-employed status, also known as professional income tax, is a relatively new tax regime in Russia, which is in the experimental stage. The main purpose of this status is to legalize the activities of freelancers, many of whom do not draw up contracts and do not pay taxes. Thus, this status can be characterized as "minimum taxes and maximum simplification". Self-employed individuals are now able to officially conduct their business while paying income taxes at a reduced rate, which promotes small business development and increases tax compliance in the country.

The experiment, regulated by Federal Law 422-FZ, will last until December 31, 2028. An important condition is that the tax rate cannot be increased during the entire experiment. In addition to Russian citizens, self-employed status is also available to citizens of Kyrgyzstan, Armenia, Belarus, and Kazakhstan. This allows a wider range of people to legally engage in entrepreneurial activity and simplifies the tax burden for the self-employed.

Taxes for the self-employed are among the lowest in Russia, and they can be paid using the "My Tax" mobile app. This makes paying taxes as simple as possible: there is no need to understand complex accounting, fill out numerous documents, or submit them to tax authorities. Today, this is the most convenient way to pay taxes for the self-employed. Furthermore, you don't need to open a special bank account to use the app—any active account, the number of which can be entered in the app, is sufficient. This simplifies the tax process and makes it accessible to a wider audience. Obtaining self-employed status is quick and easy. Simply download the "My Tax" app from the App Store or Google Play, register, and it will automatically generate an application. You will be registered the same day you submit your application. If there are grounds for refusal, you will receive a notification within a week. You can also register for self-employment on the government services website or through the web version of the "My Tax" app on the Federal Tax Service website. This process allows you to begin legal activity and earn income while complying with all legal requirements. In accordance with paragraph 4 of Article 422-FZ, categories of citizens who can become self-employed are defined. This status is intended for individuals who independently provide services or manufacture goods for sale. The law also lists groups of citizens who are prohibited from obtaining self-employed status.

  • Those who sell excisable goods, such as alcohol, tobacco, or medicines, as well as goods requiring special labeling, are prohibited—even if they were manufactured themselves. Resale is also restricted.
  • Another restriction on this status is that individual entrepreneurs cannot obtain it if they have employees hired under an employment contract. It is also unavailable to certain intermediaries.
  • Couriers also cannot be self-employed. An exception is a courier who works with an assigned cash register registered to the seller of the goods.
  • If you use other special tax regimes, for example, a simplified tax system or pay agricultural tax, you will need to opt out of this regime before becoming self-employed.

Self-employed status has an important income limitation: it must not exceed 2,400,000 rubles per year. This limit is set until the end of the experiment and will not be reduced, but it may be increased by the state in the face of inflation. If income exceeds the specified amount, the status will be automatically canceled, and all subsequent income will be subject to personal income tax at a rate of 13%. You will receive a notification of this. Alternatively, you can register as an individual entrepreneur (IE) and take advantage of the simplified tax system until the end of the year.

Taxes for the self-employed are significantly lower than taxes under a civil law contract. The rate is 4% if the contract is concluded with an individual, and 6% if with a legal entity or sole proprietor. A portion of these taxes is automatically transferred to the Social Insurance Fund. Clients often increase the payment amount to include the tax, but some indicate the cost of work without this percentage. In this case, the self-employed individual will have to pay tax on the fee they expected to receive "in hand." It is important to consider these nuances when planning income and expenses to avoid unplanned financial expenses.

It should be noted that self-employed citizens do not make deductions to the pension fund from their taxes. However, you have the opportunity to independently arrange these payments by submitting the appropriate application in the "My Tax" app. This will allow you to increase your minimum pension established by the state at the expense of the funded portion. You can make an annual contribution either as a lump sum or in installments, but it is important that the total amount of payments for the year meets the established requirements.

With the advent of this new status, some companies have begun actively using it when hiring employees. Instead of a traditional employment contract, a civil-law contract is now often signed with self-employed individuals. This allows employers to reduce tax liabilities and avoid certain requirements stipulated by the Labor Code. However, this practice may be disadvantageous for you. When employed under a civil-law contract, you lose a number of rights, including the right to sick leave. You can be fired at any time, and vacation issues will have to be resolved verbally. This means you are not protected by the guarantees of the Labor Code. If you are asked to resign in order to re-register as self-employed, we strongly recommend contacting the labor inspectorate to protect your rights.

If less than two years have passed since your dismissal and you resume your relationship with the same company as a self-employed employee under a civil-law contract, there is a possibility that a court may classify this contract as an employment contract. A key point is that the contract must be concluded with the same legal entity or individual entrepreneur for whom you previously worked. This is important to take into account to avoid potential legal consequences and protect your interests.

Relinquishing self-employed status is quick and easy. To do this, simply click the "Release from the Tax on Professional Income" button in your personal profile in the "My Tax" app. This action may be relevant if you plan to register with the employment service and begin receiving benefits or job search assistance. Make sure you understand all the nuances of the process to avoid potential problems in the future.

With self-employed status, the state continues to consider you employed, even if you do not actually perform any tasks. However, working under an employment contract at your primary place of work and fulfilling orders for clients as a self-employed person is not illegal. This gives you the opportunity to combine multiple sources of income, which can be beneficial and convenient for financial planning.

Working with the employment service without closing your self-employed status can have serious consequences. You will be required to return all benefits received. Failure to do so may result in legal action. To avoid these problems, it is recommended to close your self-employed status in advance before registering with the employment center. This will help preserve your finances and prevent legal consequences. Self-employed status is a simplified tax regime designed for individual entrepreneurs who work independently and seek to avoid strict office conditions and high tax payments. This regime offers a number of benefits, but also imposes certain restrictions, including a maximum annual income of 2,400,000 rubles. Self-employed individuals can take advantage of simplified taxation, making their activities more flexible and less expensive. Sole proprietorship A sole proprietorship (SP) is a status that allows for a broader and more diverse range of entrepreneurial activities than self-employed individuals, without establishing a legal entity. Individual entrepreneurs can open agencies, enter into contracts, and engage contractors to perform various services. Special tax regimes are available for individual entrepreneurs, simplifying paperwork and taxation compared to legal entities. This makes individual entrepreneurship an attractive choice for those looking to grow their business with minimal administrative barriers.

Individual entrepreneurs (IEs) have a significant advantage over self-employed individuals: they can act as employers. This means that they not only fulfill orders but can also hire employees under employment contracts. In this case, the individual entrepreneur is obligated to comply with all labor law requirements. They are responsible for paying sick leave and vacations, as well as making contributions to pension, medical, and social funds. Thus, individual entrepreneurs have the opportunity to expand their business by attracting employees and creating jobs.

Legal entities risk their company's assets, while individual entrepreneurs put their own property at risk. If debts arise and the entrepreneur's personal finances are insufficient to cover the obligations, the property may be auctioned by court order. This underscores the importance of financial planning and risk management for sole proprietors.

By law, a sole apartment and work tools cannot be seized in the event of debts. However, to protect work tools, it is necessary to provide evidence to the court that their absence makes it impossible to perform professional duties. Typically, when debts arise, debits from the debtor's bank accounts are the first priority. If funds in the accounts are insufficient to cover the debts, summer cottages, cars, or luxury items may be seized. It is important to know your rights and understand which assets are subject to protection in the event of financial difficulties.

While this may sound alarming, in practice, if you pay your taxes on time and carefully plan your expenses, the likelihood of finding yourself in such a situation is minimal. Proper financial management and tax compliance will help avoid problems and ensure financial stability.

Registering as an individual entrepreneur (IE) is an important step for designers providing services to individuals. The easiest way to register is to submit an application through the official website of the Federal Tax Service. In some situations, the law requires purchasing and registering a cash register. This is mandatory for designers who plan to operate with cash. Proper registration and compliance with all requirements will help avoid fines and ensure legal operation.

Opening a bank account is not mandatory, but it may be necessary in various situations. A bank account provides convenient financial management, simplifies settlements with counterparties, and allows for income and expense tracking. It is especially important for entrepreneurs and organizations that require transparency of financial transactions and the ability to accept non-cash payments. In addition, having a current account can increase customer and partner trust and simplify tax reporting.

  • for lending for business development;
  • if the amount of your transactions exceeds 100 thousand rubles;
  • if you participate in government procurement and tenders.

Funds will be refunded to the same account in the event of an overpayment of taxes.

One of the key reasons why many prefer this status is the wide choice of special tax regimes. These regimes include the simplified tax system (STS), also known as the "simplified tax system". In addition, the unified agricultural tax (ESKhN), as well as a tax patent, are available. These tax regimes offer significant advantages for entrepreneurs, allowing them to optimize tax payments and simplify accounting.

The simplified tax system makes it possible to replace several taxes with one, which is especially beneficial for individual entrepreneurs (IE). To switch to a simplified system, you need to select a taxable item, that is, determine what exactly will be taxed. This can significantly simplify the process of doing business and reduce the tax burden.

  • income, in which case the tax will be 6% (and regional legislation may reduce it to 1%);
  • "income minus expenses", then the state will have to pay 15% (and regional legislation may reduce the rate to 5%).

The Unified Agricultural Tax (USAT) is a simplified tax system specially designed for entities engaged in agriculture. This tax allows you to optimize tax liabilities and simplify accounting for farmers and agricultural enterprises. USAT is suitable for those operating in the agricultural sector, providing more favorable tax conditions, which contributes to the development of agriculture and increases its competitiveness.

A tax patent is a unique form of taxation, different from traditional methods. Unlike the standard system, where taxes are calculated based on actual income, a tax patent requires prepayment of taxes. By purchasing a patent, you pay taxes in advance for future business activities. This allows entrepreneurs to plan their financial expenses and minimize the risks associated with changes in tax legislation. A tax patent is ideal for sole proprietors and small businesses seeking to simplify tax accounting and optimize costs.

The list of patentable activities specified in Article 346.43 of the Tax Code of the Russian Federation is quite extensive and may be supplemented by regional legislation. In the field of graphics and creative professions, the following formulations from this list may be relevant:

  • photography services;
  • activities in the field of sound recording and publishing of musical works;
  • activities specialized in the field of design;
  • artistic design services;
  • development of computer software, including system software, software applications, databases, web pages, including their adaptation and modification.

The cost of a patent varies depending on potential income and geographic location. Patents can be purchased for a period of one month to one year, and they are valid only within a specific region of Russia. It is possible to register patents for several regions at once. For a more accurate calculation of the cost of a patent, it is recommended to use a special calculator available on the official website of the Tax Service. This will help you obtain up-to-date information and optimally plan your expenses.

An individual entrepreneur (IE) can transition to self-employed status and take advantage of all the benefits of this tax regime. Mandatory insurance contributions become voluntary, and there is no need to file reports, as the application automatically generates the necessary documents. The requirement to use an online cash register is also eliminated. The restrictions for obtaining self-employed status for an IE remain the same as the standard conditions. This transition allows for the optimization of tax expenses and simplifies business operations.

This approach is a convenient option for those who have already registered as an individual entrepreneur and are looking to reduce their tax burden. It is also relevant for those whose income as a self-employed person exceeds the limit of 2,400,000 rubles. In this case, all amounts above the established threshold can be taxed under the simplified tax system (STS). This will allow for tax optimization and more efficient financial management.

An individual entrepreneur is obligated to pay taxes in accordance with the tax calendar. This calendar presents all types of reporting, and it is important to pay attention to those that relate to your business. Correctly following reporting deadlines and forms will help avoid fines and financial losses.

Individual entrepreneurs are required to pay insurance contributions to the Pension Fund and the Compulsory Health Insurance Fund, in addition to taxes. These contributions are not mandatory for entrepreneurs without employees, but they provide the opportunity to take sick leave with payments and receive maternity benefits. It is important to note that payment of contributions is required even during periods when the entrepreneur is inactive and does not generate income. Likewise, reports must also be submitted regardless of whether any work was performed during this period. Compliance with these requirements will help avoid fines and ensure access to social guarantees.

Failure to timely submit "zero" reports, that is, reports for which no taxes are required, can lead to fines and the freezing of bank accounts. Timely compliance with reporting obligations is essential to avoiding negative consequences and maintaining business stability. Regularly checking report deadlines and adhering to all legal requirements will help avoid financial losses and maintain the company's reputation. Working as a sole proprietor requires a deeper understanding of the law and finances than self-employed individuals. Often, sole proprietors hire an accountant who, for a reasonable fee, regularly organizes documentation and prepares reports. This not only saves time but also avoids potential accounting errors, which is essential for a successful business. Proper bookkeeping and knowledge of tax obligations help sole proprietors effectively manage their finances and minimize risks. Self-employed individuals can deactivate their status by simply clicking a button in the app. However, sole proprietors must complete several steps. First, they must submit an application through the Tax Service website and pay the required fee. Then, it is important to make all necessary insurance payments to health and pension insurance funds, as well as pay taxes for the current tax period. If the entrepreneur had an open bank account, it must also be closed. Additionally, all employees will need to be dismissed and reports will need to be filed with the Federal Tax Service. All these steps are necessary for the proper termination of the sole proprietorship.

Sole proprietorship status is the optimal choice for those whose annual income exceeds 2,400,000 rubles, as well as for those planning to open a business with employees. However, it's important to keep in mind that this status comes with certain challenges. These include the need to independently pay taxes and prepare reports, which requires the entrepreneur to have a good knowledge of the law and the financial aspects of running a business.

Every Monday, we publish a digest of the most current vacancies for designers. Find it on the main page of our website or subscribe to our channels on Telegram and VKontakte to receive the latest offers straight to your phone.

Informal Employment

Shadow employment, also known as unofficial employment, is used by unscrupulous employers to conceal the fact of employment from government agencies. This allows them to evade taxes and mandatory social contributions, which negatively impacts the economy as a whole. Informal employment creates risks for both employees and employers, including a lack of social guarantees and legal protection.

When placing an order, be sure to sign a contract in which all important terms are detailed. The more information in the document, the higher the chances of avoiding misunderstandings and conflicts. It is better to have a more comprehensive contract than to face problems due to unwritten verbal agreements. This approach will protect your interests and ensure transparency in collaboration.

When working unofficially as a freelancer, you face a number of risks. Firstly, the lack of a formal contract can lead to disputes with the client over payment and terms of service. Secondly, an informal relationship can limit your ability to protect your rights if issues arise with the quality or deadlines of the project. Furthermore, working without an official status can negatively impact your reputation in the industry, as clients prefer to work with trusted professionals. It's important to remember that legalizing your business not only protects your interests but also promotes long-term relationships with clients.

  • You may be deceived and paid less than you verbally agreed upon, or not paid at all;
  • It will be difficult to go to court, since your relationship and agreements are not recorded anywhere;
  • You may receive large fines or even face criminal liability for tax evasion.

If you operate without a formal contract and employment with a company, you face a number of risks. The lack of a formal employment agreement can lead to problems with rights to social benefits, such as vacation, sick leave, and pension payments. In addition, in the event of a dispute with your employer, you will have a hard time defending your interests, since you will not have supporting documents. Working without a contract also deprives you of the opportunity to receive a stable income and protection from arbitrary dismissal. Therefore, it is important to consider the possibility of formalizing the relationship with the employer to ensure your rights and safety.

  • you do not have the guarantees established by labor legislation;
  • you do not accrue seniority;
  • no pension or other contributions are made on your behalf.

Court proceedings in cases of informal employment relationships are a complex task. You will need to prove the existence of an employment relationship. In addition, if the case is successfully resolved, the attention of the Federal Tax Service may be drawn to your case, since you received a salary "in an envelope" and did not pay taxes on this income. This can lead to additional legal consequences and fines.

Shadow employment and work without a contract have many disadvantages, while there are practically no advantages. All of the aspects discussed previously are different ways to legalize labor activity and obtain legal rights. It is important to choose the most appropriate format of work that will ensure the protection of your interests and rights.

Reworked text:

Read also:

  • Test assignments for designers: what they are and why they are needed
  • Career barriers: 5 tips from a psychologist for designers
  • Successful portfolio on Behance. A detailed guide
  • How much does a designer's work cost and where to look for clients
  • 8 important questions about a career and money

Profession Graphic Designer PRO

You will learn how to create corporate identity elements and graphics for business. Build a portfolio that reflects your style and demonstrates your design skills. You can launch your career in a studio or as a freelancer.

Find out more