Education

Study: Students Speak Less in Online Seminars

Study: Students Speak Less in Online Seminars

Learn: The Profession of a Methodologist from Scratch to PRO

Find out more

At the conference "Modern Digital Didactics", held on September 29, Maria Lebedeva, a leading researcher at the Laboratory of Cognitive and Linguistic Research at the A.S. Pushkin State Institute of the Russian Language, presented an interesting study. In her report, "Characteristics of Educational Communication in the Digital Space: A Study of a Corpus of Online Lessons," she detailed the methodology and results, focusing on the specifics of interaction in the educational environment. The study emphasizes the importance of analyzing online lessons for understanding current trends in didactics and educational communication. Researchers conducted a study aimed at examining communication between students and teachers in a distance learning environment. Lebedeva emphasized that the data obtained will provide a deeper understanding of the specifics of interaction within synchronous online learning and contribute to improving its effectiveness. This study is important for optimizing the educational process and improving the quality of distance learning. At the conference, Maria Lebedeva presented a report in which she hypothesized a decrease in student interactivity in online classes compared to in-person classes. However, she did not specify whether they had the opportunity to compare the results of the online communication study with those from offline classes. Skillbox Media sent a request to Maria, but has not yet received a response.

Photo: dekazigzag / Shutterstock

How the study was conducted

The study was conducted using the methods Linguistic analysis of the pedagogical corpus. In linguistics, a pedagogical corpus is an array of educational data contained in texts and speech materials. This approach allows for a deeper understanding of the language of the educational process and the identification of key characteristics used in teaching practice.

Maria and her team compiled a corpus of online lessons of Russian as a foreign language, which includes transcriptions of more than 40 online classes totaling approximately 3,500 minutes. A unique feature of this study is that the sample included practical seminars rather than lectures. To ensure a representative sample, the specialists examined lessons from various educational levels: preparatory faculty, courses, and undergraduate and graduate programs. The total number of words in the compiled corpus is approximately 250,000, allowing for an effective analysis of the specific features of teaching Russian as a foreign language.

After collecting the data, each fragment of educational communication was marked with a special mark indicating the roles of the participants in the communication, whether student or teacher. Information on the socio-demographic characteristics of the participants and their native language was also recorded. This structured information allows for a deeper analysis of interactions in the educational environment and the identification of key aspects influencing the effectiveness of learning and communication.

What results did the researchers obtain?

Maria Lebedeva argues that analyzing the content of communicative fragments using quantitative methods is impossible. Therefore, the researchers primarily focused on aspects that can be measured and counted.

One of the key metrics in communication analysis is interactivity. It characterizes the number of active interactions between participants in the communication process, measured in the total volume of speech. The researchers determined this metric by counting the number of times participants took the floor and exchanged remarks, and then dividing that number by the total volume of speech in the online lesson. The table below presents the interactivity data in the second column, along with the standard deviation (SD). The higher the value of this metric, the greater the dispersion in the data set, which may indicate a variety of communication styles and levels of participant engagement.

The study demonstrated a significant level of interactivity, especially in certain segments of the sample. As Lebedeva notes, scores above 85 indicate a high level of activity during the transition from one speaker to another. This indicates that participants are actively exchanging remarks, which emphasizes the importance of communication in this environment. High interactivity can be a key factor for studying the dynamics of communication and interaction in different groups.

The researchers analyzed two key metrics—teacher speech volume and student speech volume. The results showed that teacher speech volume significantly exceeded student speech volume by an average of 48%. It's worth noting that the study included only seminars, which involve active student participation. This contrasts with lectures, where the teacher does most of the talking, emphasizing the importance of student engagement in the learning process.

The presentation of the report "Characteristics of Educational Communication in the Digital Space: A Study of Online Lessons" at the "Modern Digital Didactics" conference represents an important source of data for studying methods and approaches to teaching in a digital environment. The report examines key aspects of online lessons, including the interactions between teachers and students, as well as the effectiveness of various communication strategies. The study focuses on the impact of digital technologies on the learning process and the creation of an educational environment conducive to active student participation. The findings may be useful for teachers and education specialists seeking to adapt their methods to the modern requirements and capabilities of digital learning.

Maria Lebedeva noted that effective language teaching methods recommend that teachers reduce their own speaking time, allowing students to speak more. Researchers have no doubt about the professionalism of teachers, but they face challenges in implementing this goal in online classes. In a distance learning environment, it's important to create an environment where students can actively participate in conversations and develop their communication skills, which requires additional effort and adaptation of teaching methods from teachers.

Read also:

Psychological factors play a key role in the effectiveness of online learning. They affect motivation, attention, and student engagement. Understanding these factors helps create more effective educational programs.

One of the main factors is motivation. Students who have clear goals and understand the meaning of the material they are learning perform better. It is important to use methods that increase intrinsic motivation, such as interesting tasks and timely feedback. Attention also significantly affects the learning process. The online format can be distracting for students, so it is important to develop strategies that help them focus. This may include the use of interactive elements, short video tutorials, and the opportunity to ask questions. Engagement plays an equally important role. Students who actively participate in discussions and interact with instructors and peers demonstrate higher academic performance. Creating a community among students can significantly increase their engagement. In conclusion, taking psychological aspects into account can significantly improve the effectiveness of online learning. Designing programs with an emphasis on student motivation, attention, and engagement promotes deeper and higher-quality learning. During data analysis, the researchers faced the question of why student speech volume remains critically low despite the high degree of interactivity. To answer this question, the number of words spoken by students and teachers was counted compared to their responses. The results showed that most students use only 1-3 words per response. Only occasionally do their utterances contain 4-10 words. Long and detailed sentences account for a very small proportion of student utterances. Thus, despite frequent exchanges with teachers and peers, students generally limit themselves to very short phrases. This raises questions about methods for encouraging more meaningful and detailed responses in the learning process.

The study's authors suggest that lack of language proficiency is not a key factor. The analyzed corpus of materials includes lessons for students with different levels of proficiency in Russian, including levels B1 and B2, which imply the ability to speak fluently and maintain a conversation.

Photo: simona pilolla 2 / Shutterstock

Maria Lebedeva emphasizes that a key aspect of digital didactics is student-centeredness. This means that digital methods and tools should promote students' active participation in the learning process, meet their individual needs and demands, and encourage self-expression and self-realization. However, the results of this study indicate that this is not currently the case. An analysis of online classes revealed a lack of student engagement, highlighting the need for improved approaches to integrating digital technologies into the educational process.

The Social Presence Model and Key Research Findings

Lebedeva noted the social presence model developed by Amy Whiteside, PhD, in rhetoric and scientific and technical communications, in 2007. This model emphasizes that it is not always possible to achieve a full sense of presence for all participants during on-screen communication. This effect is significantly enhanced when communication takes place without cameras on, and only "black squares" are displayed on the screen instead of faces.

To create a sense of presence and approximate the format of in-person communication, it is necessary to consider the three key components presented in the Whiteside model. These elements contribute to more natural and interactive communication, which is especially important in the context of remote work and online interaction. The correct combination of these factors improves the quality of interaction and increases the level of participant engagement.

  • affective aspect (emotions, humor, communication on extracurricular topics, openness);
  • interactive aspect (exchange of remarks, questions and answers);
  • social cohesion (establishing contact between interlocutors, maintaining the communication process).

Maria and her colleagues analyzed data from online lessons, studying indicators of various aspects of social presence. As a result of the study, they made several key conclusions.

  • Techniques aimed at developing social presence are very limited and are usually used only at the beginning of the lesson.
  • Social interaction between students is also limited, communication mainly occurs frontally - "teacher → group".
  • The affective aspect is practically absent or appears spontaneously - for example, thanks to a pet caught on camera.
  • At the beginning of the forced distance learning in 2020, group and paired forms of work in online classes were almost non-existent. However, by 2022, they began to be used much more often.
  • After group or paired work, the level of social presence increases. Students are much more willing to turn on their cameras and interact more actively in the lesson.

In conclusion, Maria Lebedeva emphasized that the Laboratory of Cognitive and Linguistic Studies will continue to analyze the features of educational communication in the digital environment. She noted that even at this stage, the results obtained could be useful for teachers seeking to engage students in active interaction. These findings can help develop effective teaching methods and increase student engagement in the learning process.

Read also:

  • How the traditional chain of command between teachers and students has been erased
  • Researchers from Moscow State Pedagogical University studied the phenomenon of student Zoom fatigue
  • A new version of the "hybrid" – HyFlex – is coming to universities. What is this format and why is it important?
  • "Teaching in Any Conditions", Douglas Fisher, Nancy Frey and John Hattie

The Profession of Methodologist from Scratch to PRO

You will improve your skills in developing curricula for online and offline courses. Master modern teaching practices, structure your experience, and become a more sought-after specialist.

Find out more