Contents:

Learn: The profession of a Methodologist from scratch to PRO
Find out more
Independent screenwriter and developer of e-courses with experience in the field of education since 2012. Over the course of my career, I have created over 200 courses covering various topics and formats. I also run the Nova Academy Telegram channel, where I share my knowledge and experience in online learning. My goal is to help educational institutions and individual professionals create high-quality and effective educational materials.
During their training, future methodologists study various models and tools for designing educational courses. At a theoretical level, this process seems systematic and logical. However, when beginning methodologists encounter real-world challenges from clients, they often encounter unexpected difficulties that differ significantly from their initial understanding. This contrast between theory and practice highlights the importance of a deep understanding not only of design methodology but also of client needs.
The reasons for the ineffectiveness of educational courses are often related to the fact that clients and subject matter experts do not always have the necessary knowledge about creating educational programs. This is quite natural: they are not required to be specialists in this field. The client's primary task is to define the desired learning outcomes, while the expert must have a deep understanding of the course topic. A methodologist plays a key role in translating expert knowledge into a high-quality course that helps achieve the stated goals. Clients and experts trust the methodologist, who designs the course, selecting the most appropriate approaches and tools to solve educational problems. Ideally, this type of interaction ensures the creation of an effective educational product. Clients and experts often have their own ideas about how a course should be organized and insist on them, even if they lack knowledge of methodology. Novice methodologists, faced with this pressure, are not always able to convincingly defend their point of view and propose the most effective approaches to teaching. This can lead to the stereotype that "the customer is always right," which sometimes hinders the high-quality development of educational programs. It is important to understand that successful teaching requires taking into account the scientific foundations of pedagogy and methodology, and professionals must be able to justify their proposals to achieve optimal results.

In this text, I will analyze several common situations that often arise in practice. I will show how different methodologists can react to the same circumstances, as well as the consequences and results that follow. For clarity, I will demonstrate different approaches using the example of two fictional characters.
Elena is a novice methodologist who strives to satisfy the needs of both clients and experts. She is always ready to listen to their wishes and fulfill their requirements, as she is afraid of disappointing the people she works with. Her approach to work is based on a desire for cooperation and understanding of the needs of clients, which makes her a valuable specialist in her field. However, this approach can lead to the fact that she does not always take into account her own ideas and initiatives. It is important that Elena learn to find a balance between fulfilling the wishes of others and implementing her own concepts, which will allow her to develop as a methodologist and offer original solutions.
The second heroine, Yulia, is an experienced methodologist. She confidently interacts with experts, offers a variety of solutions, and persistently defends her professional opinion. Yulia displays confidence and competence, which makes her an important member of the team.
"No need for any custom development, there are no resources for that!"
When creating a goal-setting course for managers of a small retail company, it is important to start with a deep understanding of the target audience. However, if the client indicates a lack of time and requires prompt order fulfillment, it is necessary to use available data for rapid analysis. You can conduct a survey of company employees to study their needs and expectations from the course. In addition, it is worth considering best practices in the field of goal-setting, adapting them to the specifics of the retail industry. It is important to develop a course structure that will take into account the main problems and tasks that managers face in their daily work. This will create an effective and in-demand product that will help develop goal-setting skills in executives and improve company results.
Elena decides to collaborate with the client and immediately begins developing a course based on the content provided by the goal-setting coach. This working strategy allows for the creation of an effective educational product that meets the needs of the target audience and takes into account current trends in goal-setting.
Once the course is completed, it undergoes focus group testing, which elicits numerous negative comments. Executives note that the course content does not align with their work objectives, necessitating significant revisions. The client remains dissatisfied and believes that the course's problems are due to the methodologist's shortcomings, not to the coach's failure to research the target audience.
Yulia understands that the course must take into account the level of the target audience, as well as their needs and challenges. Therefore, she develops a program tailored to the specific needs of the participants. This allows for the creation of highly relevant and effective content that will answer current questions and solve the target group's pressing problems. Taking into account the characteristics and needs of the audience, Yulia strives to ensure a high level of engagement and material absorption, which ultimately contributes to the participants' practical achievements.
- She explains to the client why target audience research is necessary and why this stage cannot be skipped, clearly conveying that without it, the course may be useless.
- She offers options for reducing research time. For this purpose, Yulia always has a list of questions ready for target audience research. She poses these questions to the client.
- If it is not possible to conduct a full-scale casting, she limits herself to interviews with a few representatives of the target audience. This helps her understand their motivations, needs, and attitudes.
The focus group testing results showed a high rating for the course, which led to its acceptance by the client with minimal adjustments. This confirms the effectiveness of the developed material and its compliance with the target audience's expectations.
"No need for practical assignments, just make it beautiful and engaging!"
Our specialists have received a new order. This time, they need to develop a course for cosmetics salespeople to confidently navigate a new product. The client insists that the course contain only theoretical information, that is, information the salespeople need to remember about the product. Practical exercises are not required. The main focus should be on presenting the theory in an interesting and engaging way to make the learning process as effective and memorable as possible.

Elena believes that the client has a better understanding of the training objectives, so she develops a course focused on theoretical aspects. She uses a storytelling method, which makes the learning process engaging and interesting. This approach not only effectively assimilates the material but also maintains a high level of participant engagement.
The training results were satisfactory for both the client and the salespeople. However, a month after completing the course, only 30% of the salespeople successfully passed the test on knowledge of the new product. The client was disappointed because the course, although interesting, did not deliver the expected benefits. In his view, the responsibility for this lies with the methodologist.
In a similar situation with scientific research, Yulia explains to a client that his idea of memorizing information is wrong. Memorization does not happen automatically when familiarizing yourself with the material - it requires active engagement, which is called retrieval practice. Without this technique, new information is quickly forgotten, and simply repeating the course does not solve the problem. Therefore, Yulia emphasizes the need to include exercises in the course aimed at retrieving and recalling new information, which will significantly improve the effectiveness of learning and knowledge retention.
Yulia takes a course with memorization exercises. A month after completing the course, salespeople demonstrate excellent results in assessing knowledge of the new product, which leads to customer satisfaction.
"Do as the expert says - he understands the topic better!"
The launch of a new course is dedicated to the complex technical topic of "Personal Protective Equipment" for workers at a metallurgical plant. Information on this topic is provided by an expert, but communicating with him is difficult. He consistently asserts his opinion, uses authority, and believes he knows how to best present the material. The client also supports the expert's position, arguing that his opinion should be decisive. It is important to find a balance between expert opinion and the needs of the audience to ensure high-quality training and compliance with industrial safety standards.
Elena designs the course based on her expert opinion. With over 20 years of professional experience, she knows exactly how to effectively convey information to students. Her approach ensures that topics are presented in an accessible and understandable manner, which facilitates successful learning.
The course proved difficult to understand and excessive in information. After its completion, employees had more questions than they knew on the topic. The client blames the methodologist for this. The expert provided excellent content, but Elena failed to present it effectively. Optimization of the material delivery is necessary to improve learning and participant satisfaction.
Yulia has already had a similar experience. She understands that many experts and clients don't appreciate the importance of a methodologist, viewing them merely as a technical assistant. Therefore, at the first meeting with the client and the expert, Yulia immediately outlines her responsibilities and clarifies the role of the subject matter expert. She emphasizes that a methodologist is a qualified specialist with knowledge in developing effective educational programs. This understanding helps set appropriate expectations and fosters productive collaboration.
When designing a course, many factors must be considered, including learning theory, cognitive load, learner psychology, and design algorithms. A good course is not simply content provided by a subject matter expert, but a methodologically structured system. Interaction between the methodologist and the expert should be equal, with each responsible for their own area. The expert is responsible for creating the substantive portion of the course, while the methodologist focuses on the effective delivery of the material. Thus, the methodologist's opinion becomes key in the course development process.
The expert highly praised the final course, which was clear and accessible to staff. The training is easy, and participants successfully master the material. The course demonstrated its effectiveness, and the client was satisfied with the results.
What are the conclusions?
The main idea I want to convey through these examples is that, to successfully develop educational programs, methodologists need more than just knowledge of methodology and tools. High communication skills are also key. These skills are just as important as a theoretical foundation. The inability to conduct a constructive dialogue with clients and experts, as well as the lack of the ability to convincingly and persistently persuade them when they are mistaken in their ideas about course creation, can lead to significant shortcomings in the final product. Ultimately, responsibility for training design falls on the methodologist, and it is they who will be blamed for potential problems. Therefore, the development of communication skills is an integral part of the professional training of methodologists.
I will give an example from personal experience. One day, a client, similar to the one described in the first part of the article, declared that they didn't have time to determine the needs of their target audience: "Let's do without this, the course is urgently needed!" The course required training salespeople on a computer program that would help maintain an up-to-date product selection on store shelves.
During our meeting, we discovered that the store had been using the software for quite some time, but the sales associates weren't using its functionality. The client wanted to develop an engaging, game-based course with gamification elements to clearly demonstrate how to effectively use the software. This approach would not only increase employee engagement but also significantly improve their proficiency with the tool.
I analyzed the software and concluded that it was intuitive enough to be quickly mastered without the need for training. Therefore, the problem likely wasn't a lack of knowledge among the sales associates about how to use the software. They simply didn't seem to be paying attention.
I explained the situation to the client and suggested conducting a small study to gather their opinions. He agreed. During our conversations, the sales associates admitted they were concerned about reprimands from the manager if he began receiving messages about inventory shortages. This internal pressure prevents them from using the program effectively.

Ultimately, the course The course was implemented, but its content changed significantly. We weren't simply training users to use the program; we were also striving to change salespeople's stereotypes. This, of course, increased the development time, but ultimately, the course achieved its intended goals. Had we followed the client's initial requirements and focused solely on training, it would have led to much greater frustration and wasted time, without any tangible results. Experience does play a significant role in the ability to effectively handle various situations. However, what should methodologists who are just beginning their careers do? I believe there are several helpful recommendations that can significantly simplify this process. First, it's important to continually learn and develop in your field. Reading specialized literature and participating in webinars will help deepen your knowledge and broaden your horizons. Second, it's worth establishing connections with more experienced colleagues for support and advice. Sharing experiences with other methodologists can be a valuable resource during difficult times. Third, practice is key. Regularly applying acquired knowledge in real-world situations will help you adapt faster and increase your confidence. These steps will help newcomers become more confident and successful methodologists.
- Understanding your role and value in the project process. This builds self-confidence. It is important to clearly answer the question: "Why am I here? To make the training effective and interesting for students, or just to do everything as the client says?"
- Thoroughly prepare for meetings with clients and experts. It is important to plan it in advance, think through the questions you want to ask, and prepare compelling arguments in support of your opinion.
- Training on a communication course or training. Effective communication is also a skill, not just an innate talent, and it can also be learned. Training does not necessarily have to be lengthy, but it does require practice.
- Setting personal boundaries. This is a little more difficult. It is important to learn to say "no." Personally, a session with a psychologist helped me learn to set boundaries.
Study additional materials:
- How a methodologist can start earning money as a freelancer
- How to work with experts: a guide for methodologists
- 5 typical difficulties that methodologists encounter with experts
- What do methodologists do in schools, kindergartens, secondary vocational schools, universities, and EdTech?
The Profession of Methodologist from Scratch to PRO
You will improve your skills in developing curricula for online and offline courses. You will master modern pedagogical practices, structure your experience and become a more sought-after specialist.
Find out more
