Contents:

Learn: Educational Programs Methodologist
Learn moreThis article provides information on how to optimize your content for search engines. We will look at effective methods and strategies that will help improve the visibility of your site in search results. You will learn about the importance of keywords, text structure, and other aspects that contribute to an increase in SEO ranking. We'll also discuss how to properly use meta tags and descriptions to attract more users to your website. Read on for helpful tips on optimizing your content and improving its search engine performance.
- How an American teacher demonstrates the inconsistency of grading using skateboarding as an example;
- How subjectivity influences grades and why teachers really love grades;
- How grades influence learning motivation.
Grading on various scales, whether 1-5, A-F, or 1-100, is a common practice in education, but it is highly controversial. Scientists still haven't reached a consensus on whether grades are more beneficial or harmful. Research results on this issue are varied. The advantages of such grading systems are usually considered to be the following: they set clear expectations for students, promote motivation, allow for objective comparison of achievements, and help teachers track student progress. It is important to consider that the effective use of assessments requires their meaningful implementation into the educational process in order to minimize potential negative consequences and improve the quality of learning.
- They help both the teacher and the student understand the latter's level and whether there are any knowledge gaps;
- They allow the teacher to analyze the effectiveness of their own work;
- They motivate students to study and instill a desire to achieve better results.
Let's consider why seemingly obvious arguments are not always effective. Often, the reason is that the perception of information depends on individual factors, such as personal experience, biases, and emotional state. In addition, the context in which information is presented can significantly influence its perception. It is important to consider that different groups of people can respond to the same arguments very differently. Therefore, to achieve maximum argumentation effectiveness, it is necessary to tailor the approach to each specific audience.
Does an A count for true success or just luck?
An American physics professor known as "Dr. Tae" drew an interesting comparison between education and skateboarding. He noted that the process of learning to skateboard provides an excellent analogy for the modern educational process. In both cases, the most important thing is not simply the assimilation of theoretical knowledge, but the acquisition of practical skills. Success in learning depends on the ability to apply theory in practice, which is especially relevant in a rapidly changing world. Therefore, modern education should emphasize practical experience that allows students to develop the necessary skills to solve real-world problems.
In skateboarding, every trick requires consistent practice until it's executed flawlessly. Simply understanding and memorizing a move isn't enough to achieve mastery. You've truly mastered a trick only when you can perform it confidently and consistently. Regular practice and persistence are the keys to successfully mastering skateboarding tricks.
Setting a specific time frame for learning skateboarding skills is impossible. Some people can master complex tricks in just a few days thanks to their natural ability, while others will need months of dedicated training. Developing lasting skills, rather than achieving success by accident, requires repeatedly falling, getting up, and continuing to practice. Consistency and patience are key to mastering skateboarding.
Dr. Tae argues that there's no point in grading in skateboarding. Such grades can be demotivating and don't reflect a student's true skills and knowledge. For example, a failed trick may result in a low grade, but success can depend not only on skill but also on luck. A successful ramp run can be achieved through practice or chance. Therefore, instead of grades, it's worth focusing on the learning process and the development of a skateboarder's individual skills. Skill has a unique property—it can't be faked, copied, or hinted at. You either have the necessary skills, or you don't. The standard performance evaluation system, which includes tests and points as a motivating element, can easily be circumvented: you can find the answer online or ask a neighbor. Even a favorable attitude from a teacher towards a student can result in a minimum score or a "pull-up" grade. Thus, the absence of grades significantly changes the role of teachers in the educational process—they become not just evaluators, but mentors, helping students develop their skills and abilities.
Are grades really that useful for teachers and students?
A recent study has confirmed a widely known fact: a teacher's subjective opinion of a particular student can significantly influence their assessment. Between 2019 and 2020, researchers compared grades assigned by teachers with the results of state exams, which use a test-based assessment system that eliminates subjectivity. The results showed that students perceived by teachers as pleasant, conscientious, and motivated were more likely to receive high grades. The study highlights the importance of an objective approach in the education system and the need to eliminate bias in student assessment.
Journalist Frida Vigdorova, who previously worked as a school teacher in the mid-1930s, describes an interesting episode from her teaching practice in her story “My Class”. Vigdorova shares a story told by an experienced teacher, emphasizing the importance and complexity of the educational process. This episode illustrates how the interaction between teacher and student can influence the formation of a child’s personality and development.
There was a young teacher at our school, and I was fortunate enough to attend her lessons. They were conducted in accordance with all methodological standards. I asked her about the class: “How do your students behave?” “They’re wonderful,” she replied. I asked about the boy in the front row: “What can you say about him?” — “This is an excellent student, he gets only A’s. He is very smart and quick-witted.” Then I pointed to the black-eyed boy in the blue shirt: “What about him?” — “He is a C student, an average student, but at the same time disciplined.” And finally, I asked about the snub-nosed boy with freckles: “What about him?” — “He gets B’s, but in arithmetic his grades are always higher than A’s.” And so, Natalya Andreyevna continued: “Suddenly all these kids—black-eyed and blue-eyed, dark-skinned and fair-haired, freckled—began to look alike, and the only thing that distinguished them was their grades: a B student, a C student, a D student, an A student.”
This situation emphasizes how important it is not only to evaluate students by their academic performance, but also to pay attention to the individuality of each of them.
It's a misconception that grading provides teachers with an objective understanding of their work. Grades don't always reflect the actual level of students' knowledge and skills. They can depend on a variety of factors, including teaching methods, individual student characteristics, and even the classroom atmosphere. Therefore, it's important to view grades as a tool for assessment, not a final verdict on the quality of the educational process.
A grade isn't just an assessment of knowledge; it's a tool that grants teachers certain powers in the teaching process. Some educators believe that grades serve the benefit of students, allowing them to reward success and correct shortcomings. For example, a teacher might raise a grade for active participation in a school event or lower it for a late essay submission. This is precisely why many teachers around the world continue to use grading systems, according to American teacher Jennifer Hurley.
In her article, "Why I Should Have Stopped Grading or Stopped Teaching," Hurley shares her experience changing the grading system to foster positive behavior in students. She draws a parallel with how dog owners use treats to train their pets to behave in certain ways. She believes that teachers, including herself, justified such approaches by claiming they were for the benefit of students. The underlying idea was that influencing students and helping them make more informed choices was important. Hurley emphasizes that proper assessment can help students develop the skills they need for their future.
The problem is that many students are unable to fully grasp the true meaning of assessment, even if it is based on positive intentions. This complicates the process of making the right decisions they should be encouraged to make as a result of such assessment. Understanding the role of assessment in the educational process is an important aspect that requires attention from both students and teachers.
Students and adults can usually understand the reasons why their work received a particular grade. However, children are often unable to analyze the meaning behind grades such as a B, C, or A. As Russian educator and scholar Shalva Amonashvili pointed out in his 2007 article, children lack the necessary level of reflection to understand this process. The emotions associated with receiving a grade—whether the joy of praise or the disappointment of criticism—often overshadow their ability to think more deeply about the essence of the situation and what led to a particular grade. Therefore, it is important to develop self-reflection skills in children so that they can better understand their achievements and mistakes.
Of course, I am happy to help you with editing the text. Please provide the text you wish to revise.
Alexey Vorontsov, a renowned Russian educator, in his article "Control and Assessment Independence of Primary School Students as the Foundation for Adolescent Academic Independence," raises the pressing issue of teachers' "monopolization" of assessment. He argues that this situation hinders the development of self-assessment skills in children. Vorontsov emphasizes the importance of involving younger students in the assessment process, which promotes their independence and critical thinking. Encouraging students to actively participate in assessing their work and achievements helps them develop responsibility for their own learning and success. Therefore, it is necessary to reconsider approaches to assessing academic achievements in order to create conditions for the full development of independence in adolescents. Students often do not recognize the limits of their knowledge. Unaware of their limitations, they are reluctant to learn. The decision about when and what knowledge to present to an adult for assessment is usually made externally, not by the student. Students rarely participate in determining whether they have mastered a topic and whether they are ready to move on to new material. The opportunity to choose the level of difficulty of an assignment in accordance with their abilities and aspirations for learning is also extremely rare. This highlights one of the problems of the modern educational system: students lack the opportunity to independently monitor and evaluate their knowledge.
Grades play a vital role in shaping children's personalities. In their 2011 article, "From a C to an A: The Facets of School Grades," researchers from the Institute of Sociology of Education of the Russian Academy of Education presented data showing that, as children age, teachers increasingly cite grading bias as a cause of aggressive behavior. This underscores the need to reconsider approaches to grading to create a more equitable and supportive educational environment.
In this study, sociologists surveyed 3,056 fifth- through ninth-grade students from 22 Moscow schools. The authors examined factors influencing the motivation of three groups of students—C, B, and A students—as well as their attitudes toward grading. The results showed that nearly one in six low-performing students experiences not only biased but also negative attitudes from teachers during their learning process. This highlights the importance of understanding the classroom climate and its impact on children's academic performance and self-esteem.
Research has shown that scientists have discovered important facts about…
- 57.6% of surveyed schoolchildren believe that teachers objectively evaluate their knowledge;
- 12.2% believe that teachers underestimate their grades;
- 3.5% indicate that teachers overestimate them;
- 19.6% were undecided.
Sociologists noted that almost 20% of surveyed schoolchildren could not give a clear answer to questions about how their knowledge was assessed. This indicates that a significant number of students do not understand the criteria by which teachers assign grades. Lack of clarity in assessment criteria reduces motivation and does not contribute to the development of skills and knowledge in students. For assessment to truly become an incentive for learning, it is necessary for students to understand the standards by which they are assessed.

Revised text:
We recommend that you familiarize yourself with additional materials.
Tatyana Klyachko discusses the problem of grade devaluation in the education system, considering the impact of this phenomenon on the academic The process and motivation of students. The devaluation of grades leads to a decline in the quality of education, as the emphasis shifts from a deep understanding of the material to achieving high scores. This phenomenon also creates a distorted value system in students, where the importance of knowledge and skills gives way to the desire for high grades. Tatyana emphasizes the need to revise assessment approaches to restore the emphasis on developing critical thinking and practical skills. It is important to create an educational environment in which grades are not an end in themselves, but a tool for self-development and improving the quality of knowledge.
Educational Programs Methodologist
You will go through the full cycle of creating an educational product from scratch. Learn to design curricula for online and offline courses. Become a versatile specialist—you can launch your own project or get a job as a methodologist at a large company.
Find out more
